Story perspectives

Celtic's Scales Avoids Own Goal After Controversial Offside Call

11/25/2025

Summary

Story summary

Celtic defender Liam Scales' potential own goal against St Mirren was ruled out after offside call.
Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher said Scales was fortunate the goal was disallowed and explained Scales moved toward ball, influencing video assistant referee decision.
Ex-Cardiff City striker Jay Bothroyd disagreed, arguing Scales focused on the ball and not affected by offside.
St Mirren manager Stephen Robinson described the decision as subjective.

History

Historical Context

The Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system was first implemented in international football in 2016, following years of debate about officiating accuracy. FIFA reported VAR's use in over 300 matches during its inaugural year, highlighting its significant impact on game outcomes. The ongoing discussions about VAR's subjective interpretations, particularly regarding offside rules, reflect the evolving nature of fairness in football officiating.

1 of 2

Story summary

Celtic defender Liam Scales' potential own goal against St Mirren was ruled out after offside call.
Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher said Scales was fortunate the goal was disallowed and explained Scales moved toward ball, influencing video assistant referee decision.
Ex-Cardiff City striker Jay Bothroyd disagreed, arguing Scales focused on the ball and not affected by offside.
St Mirren manager Stephen Robinson described the decision as subjective.

1 / 2