Full Breakdown
Controversy Surrounds Rep. Andy Biggs' Comments on National Guard Shooting
11/27/2025, 10:19:45 PM
Incident Overview: Shooting of National Guard Troops
On Wednesday, two National Guard troops were critically injured in a shooting incident in Washington, D.C. The event has sparked significant political discourse, particularly surrounding comments made by Representative Andy Biggs (R-AZ) in response to the situation.
Biggs' Controversial Remarks
In a post on X, Biggs linked the shooting to remarks made by Representative Elissa Slotkin (D-MI), who, along with five other Democrats, appeared in a video discussing the rights of military members to disobey illegal orders. Biggs accused Slotkin of "sowing the seeds of a soft coup" and suggested that her statements contributed to a climate where National Guardsmen might harm American citizens. He stated, "After Elissa Slotkin sowed the seeds of a soft coup... two Guardsmen have now been tragically assaulted in DC. Disgusting."
Political Reactions and Criticism
Biggs' comments have drawn widespread condemnation from political analysts and observers. Critics argue that his remarks are an example of "narrative engineering" rather than responsible leadership. Mike Young, a political advocate, emphasized that Slotkin and her colleagues were reiterating a fundamental principle for service members: the obligation to refuse illegal commands. Lawyer Tom Ryan criticized Biggs for speculating on the shooter's motives, stating, "Hey Andy!!! You have no idea what this shooter’s motive was! But sure, go ahead and make crap up!" Additionally, Gregg Nunziata, executive director of the Society for the Rule of Law, labeled Biggs' tweet as "disgusting."
Context of Slotkin's Comments
Slotkin's video, which has been criticized by conservative figures, aimed to remind military personnel of their duty to uphold the law, particularly in the face of potentially unlawful orders. This principle is a cornerstone of military ethics and is taught to service members during their training.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
While Biggs' comments suggest a direct connection between Slotkin's statements and the shooting, there is no evidence presented that supports this claim. The motives behind the shooting remain unclear, and the lack of information regarding the shooter's intent has led to further speculation and debate.
Verbatim Quotes
- “Two Guardsmen have now been tragically assaulted in DC. Disgusting.” — Rep. Andy Biggs (R-AZ)
- “That is not leadership. It is narrative engineering,” — Mike Young, Political Advocate
- “Hey Andy!!! You have no idea what this shooter’s motive was! But sure, go ahead and make crap up!” — Tom Ryan, Lawyer
- “What's disgusting is this tweet,” — Gregg Nunziata, Executive Director, Society for the Rule of Law
The incident and subsequent comments highlight the contentious political climate surrounding military discourse and the responsibilities of elected officials in addressing sensitive issues.
