Apple Challenges India's Antitrust Body Over Potential $38 Billion Fine

Apple Inc. has initiated legal proceedings in the Delhi High Court against the Competition Commission of India (CCI) regarding the application of India's new antitrust law. This law allows for penalties based on a company's global turnover, which could result in fines of up to $38 billion for Apple. The company argues that this method of calculating penalties is "unconstitutional, grossly disproportionate, [and] unjust." The legal challenge comes amid ongoing investigations by the CCI, which has been examining complaints from a coalition of Indian startups and Match Group, the owner of Tinder. These complaints allege that Apple engages in "abusive conduct" by mandating developers to use its in-app purchase (IAP) system, which they claim imposes excessive commissions.

CNBC

The CCI's scrutiny of Apple began in December 2021 when it expressed a "prima facie view" that Apple's IAP system restricts developers' freedom to choose their payment processing systems. This investigation has been fueled by complaints from various developers who argue that Apple's policies limit competition and inflate costs. As a result, the CCI's final verdict on the matter remains pending, with significant implications for Apple's operations in India.

CNBC

Despite the ongoing legal challenges, Apple has experienced substantial growth in the Indian market. The company recorded its highest-ever quarterly shipments in India, reaching 5 million units in the third quarter of 2025, according to data from IDC. This growth positions Apple as one of the fastest-growing smartphone brands in the country, highlighting the importance of the Indian market to its global strategy.

CNBC

Apple has not provided detailed comments regarding the ongoing legal proceedings. However, the company's position emphasizes its belief that the CCI's approach to calculating fines is fundamentally flawed. The CCI, on the other hand, has not issued a statement in response to Apple's legal challenge, as the investigation is still ongoing.

CNBC

Critics of Apple's practices, including the coalition of Indian startups, argue that the company's policies create an unfair marketplace that stifles competition. They contend that Apple's mandatory IAP system disproportionately affects smaller developers, who may struggle to absorb the high commissions imposed by the tech giant.

CNBC

While Apple asserts that the CCI's penalty calculation method is unjust, the CCI's investigation is based on allegations of anti-competitive behavior. The discrepancy between Apple's claims and the CCI's findings underscores the complexity of the case and the potential for differing interpretations of the law.

CNBC

The outcome of Apple's legal challenge could set a significant precedent for how antitrust laws are applied in India, particularly concerning foreign companies operating in the country. As the CCI continues its investigation, the tech industry will be closely monitoring developments in this case.

CNBC