Full Breakdown
Tragic House Fire in St. James Claims Lives of Mother and Son
12/1/2025, 8:32:03 PM
Incident Overview
A devastating house fire occurred on Sunday afternoon, December 1, 2025, in St. James, New York, resulting in the deaths of a mother and her adult son. The fire broke out around 3:15 p.m. at a two-story residence located on Fifty Acre Road South. First responders reported heavy smoke and flames engulfing the home, prompting an extensive emergency response.
Victims Identified
The victims were identified as Christine Lehmann, 52, and her son Nicholas Lehmann, 25. Both were residents of the home. Ronald Montagna, 91, the homeowner, was hospitalized for smoke inhalation and burns but is expected to recover. Montagna had been renting rooms to several tenants, including the Lehmanns.
Fire Response and Investigation
The St. James Fire Department, along with seven other mutual aid crews, dispatched approximately 80 firefighters to combat the blaze. The fire was brought under control within two hours, with crews remaining on the scene until around 5:30 p.m. The cause of the fire is currently under investigation, but authorities have indicated that it does not appear to be suspicious.
Eyewitness Accounts
Anthony Capasso, a tenant who rented a room from Montagna, expressed his shock at the incident, stating, "You never think it’s gonna be you." He noted that the Lehmanns had only lived in the home for a few months, and described Christine as a hardworking individual who often spent her days off at home with her son, who had special needs.
Community Impact
The fire has left a profound impact on the local community, with residents expressing their sorrow over the loss. Capasso remarked on the rapid spread of the fire, indicating that the Lehmanns likely had little time to escape. The tragedy has raised concerns among the surviving tenants regarding the circumstances leading to the fire, particularly given Montagna's smoking habits.
Official Statements
Suffolk County police have urged anyone with information about the fire to contact the Homicide Squad Detectives. Assistant Chief Daniel Keegan of the St. James Fire Department stated, "We made a very aggressive effort to get to the victims. Unfortunately, two individuals have succumbed to the injuries."
Conclusion
As the investigation continues, the community mourns the loss of Christine and Nicholas Lehmann. The incident serves as a stark reminder of the dangers posed by residential fires and the importance of fire safety measures.
