Story perspectives

Third Circuit Rules Alina Habba's Appointment Unlawful

12/1/2025

Summary

Story summary

The Third Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on December 1, 2025, that Alina Habba unlawfully served as U.S. Attorney for New Jersey.
The ruling, issued unanimously, upheld the lower court's decision that Habba's appointment violated the Federal Vacancies Reform Act and bypassed Senate confirmation.
The court found Habba had been acting without legal authority since her term expired in July.
The decision could have broad implications for other Trump-appointed U.S. attorneys nationwide.

History

Historical Context

The Federal Vacancies Reform Act, enacted on October 21, 1998, established procedures for filling federal vacancies, requiring Senate confirmation for appointments. This law emerged from concerns over executive power and accountability, particularly after the Watergate scandal. The recent Third Circuit ruling against Alina Habba underscores ongoing legal challenges to appointments made during the Trump administration, potentially reshaping future federal appointment practices.

1 of 2

Story summary

The Third Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on December 1, 2025, that Alina Habba unlawfully served as U.S. Attorney for New Jersey.
The ruling, issued unanimously, upheld the lower court's decision that Habba's appointment violated the Federal Vacancies Reform Act and bypassed Senate confirmation.
The court found Habba had been acting without legal authority since her term expired in July.
The decision could have broad implications for other Trump-appointed U.S. attorneys nationwide.

1 / 2