Story perspectives

Critique Unveils Anti-Empathy Rhetoric in Conservative Circles

12/1/2025

Summary

Story summary

Amanda Marcotte critiques Allie Beth Stuckey's anti-empathy rhetoric as rooted in a longstanding Christian right narrative.
Stuckey's book Toxic Empathy claims empathy is harmful, a view she popularized through her podcast.
Marcotte notes that Stuckey denies LGBTQ+ identities and promotes women's submission, framed as relatable by her feminine presentation.
The analysis argues this approach gains traction among conservatives while masking extremist views and manipulating the meaning of empathy.

1 of 1

Story summary

Amanda Marcotte critiques Allie Beth Stuckey's anti-empathy rhetoric as rooted in a longstanding Christian right narrative.
Stuckey's book Toxic Empathy claims empathy is harmful, a view she popularized through her podcast.
Marcotte notes that Stuckey denies LGBTQ+ identities and promotes women's submission, framed as relatable by her feminine presentation.
The analysis argues this approach gains traction among conservatives while masking extremist views and manipulating the meaning of empathy.