Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

VAR Drama: Mateta's Penalty Retake Sparks Debate

12/2/2025

41 5

Summary

Story summary

In a Premier League match, Crystal Palace forward Jean-Philippe Mateta was fouled by Leny Yoro, earning a penalty.
The initial penalty was retaken after a VAR intervention ruled that Mateta touched the ball twice.
Former referee Dermot Gallagher supported the retake, citing a rule change, while Jay Bothroyd disagreed, saying Mateta bore responsibility for poor technique.
Manchester United won 2-1, with goals from Mason Mount and Joshua Zirkzee.

1 of 1

Story summary

In a Premier League match, Crystal Palace forward Jean-Philippe Mateta was fouled by Leny Yoro, earning a penalty.
The initial penalty was retaken after a VAR intervention ruled that Mateta touched the ball twice.
Former referee Dermot Gallagher supported the retake, citing a rule change, while Jay Bothroyd disagreed, saying Mateta bore responsibility for poor technique.
Manchester United won 2-1, with goals from Mason Mount and Joshua Zirkzee.