Full Breakdown
Craig Carton Set to Return to WFAN for Afternoon Drive Show
12/3/2025, 10:53:42 AM
Major Programming Changes at WFAN
Craig Carton is reportedly finalizing a deal to return to WFAN, marking his third stint at the prominent New York sports radio station. According to reports from The Athletic, Carton is expected to take over the afternoon drive slot, which currently features Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber from 2 p.m. to 7 p.m. Once Carton returns, Roberts and Barber will shift to the midday slot from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. The current midday hosts, Brandon Tierney and Sal Licata, are anticipated to be removed from the weekday lineup altogether. The changes are expected to take effect in January 2026.
Background on Craig Carton's Career
Carton, 56, first joined WFAN in 2007, co-hosting a successful morning show with Boomer Esiason until his departure in 2017 due to legal issues stemming from a Ponzi scheme related to gambling debts. He was sentenced to three and a half years in prison but was released early in 2020. Following his release, Carton returned to WFAN, co-hosting an afternoon show with Roberts until 2023, when he left to work on FS1's "The Carton Show." After the cancellation of his subsequent program, "Breakfast Ball," speculation about his return to WFAN intensified.
Key Figures in the Lineup Changes
The anticipated changes at WFAN also involve Chris McMonigle, the overnight host, who is viewed as a leading candidate to co-host the afternoon show alongside Carton. Meanwhile, Licata has publicly expressed confidence about retaining his position, stating, “He can come back all he wants. He's not taking my spot.” The reshuffling comes amid a broader context of competition, as ESPN Radio recently revamped its lineup, further intensifying the rivalry in the New York sports radio market.
Criticism & Opposition
While Carton's return is generating excitement among some fans, it also raises concerns among others regarding the implications for existing hosts. The removal of Tierney and Licata from the lineup has sparked discussions about the station's direction and the impact on its current programming. Critics may view this as a move that prioritizes Carton's controversial history over the contributions of established hosts.
Official Statements & Responses
No official statements have been released by WFAN or Audacy regarding the impending changes. However, industry insiders have noted that Carton's connection with Chris Oliviero, the chief business officer of Audacy, may have facilitated his return. Oliviero previously brought Carton back to WFAN after his prison sentence, indicating a strong professional relationship.
What's Next
As Carton prepares for his return, the sports radio landscape in New York is poised for significant shifts. The full impact of these changes will likely unfold in January 2026, as listeners adjust to the new lineup and the dynamics of the station evolve.
