Vatican Commission Concludes Against Women Deacons

A Vatican commission established by Pope Francis has determined that women will not be ordained as deacons, a decision that continues to uphold the Catholic Church's tradition of an all-male clergy. The report, published on December 4, 2025, summarizes the commission's work over several years and reflects a split in theological perspectives on the issue. While the commission's assessment is strong, it does not allow for a definitive judgment on the matter, suggesting that further study is necessary.

America Magazine

Pope Francis initiated the first study commission on the female diaconate in 2016, responding to requests from the International Union of Superiors General, which represents female religious orders. Following a lack of consensus, a second commission was formed in 2020, led by Cardinal Giuseppe Petrocchi. The commission's findings indicate that there are two irreconcilable theological schools regarding women's ordination: one supports the inclusion of women in the diaconate, while the other maintains that such ordination is incompatible with Church tradition.

America MagazineCruxA divided papal commission votes against women deacons for now

The commission's report states that historical and theological investigations currently exclude the possibility of admitting women to the diaconate as a degree of Holy Orders. In a notable vote, the commission reached a 7-1 decision against the ordination of women as deacons, although it acknowledged the need for ongoing theological and pastoral study. The report also highlighted that only 22 submissions were received from various groups, which the commission deemed insufficient to represent the global Church's perspective.

America Magazine

The commission's discussions revealed a significant divide among members. Some argued that the diaconate is oriented toward service and could therefore include women, while others insisted on the unity of the sacrament of Holy Orders, which traditionally excludes women. Cardinal Petrocchi noted that the lack of consensus on fundamental doctrinal issues necessitates a cautious approach to the topic.

America Magazine

In his report to Pope Leo XIV, Cardinal Petrocchi emphasized the need for further theological exploration and the establishment of new lay ministries for women. He stated, “This recognition will be a prophetic sign, especially where women still suffer situations of gender discrimination.” The commission's findings have drawn criticism from advocates for women's ordination, who argue that the Church's stance is rooted in outdated traditions and fails to recognize the contributions of women in ecclesial roles.

Vatican Commission Splits on Women Deacons as Current Answer Remains No

Opponents of the commission's decision, including members of the Women's Ordination Conference, expressed disappointment, stating that the Vatican's refusal to consider women's ordination reflects a broader reluctance to embrace gender equality within the Church. Phyllis Zagano, a researcher and member of the previous commission, criticized the report for presenting the topic negatively, arguing that it lacks a robust theological basis for its conclusions.

Crux

The commission's report leaves the door open for further study, indicating that the conversation around women's roles in the Church is far from over. Future discussions may focus on expanding lay ministries for women and addressing the broader implications of gender equality within the Church's governance and ministry.

The Vatican closes the door on women deacons

• “The problems relating to the diaconal ordination of women remain open to further theological and pastoral study, holding firm to the principle of the ‘communio hierarchica’ [hierarchical communion] which assigns the final decision on these issues to the Magisterium of the Church, as an authoritative response to questions present in some sectors of the People of God.” — Cardinal Giuseppe Petrocchi

America Magazine

• “ “The long report does not present evidence or a theological argument, only the opinion that more study is needed.” — Phyllis Zagano

Crux

• “This recognition will be a prophetic sign, especially where women still suffer situations of gender discrimination.” — Cardinal Giuseppe Petrocchi

America Magazine

The Vatican's decision not to ordain women as deacons reflects ongoing theological debates and the complexities surrounding gender roles within the Catholic Church.

Crux