Calls for Independent Investigation into Miss Universe Pageant

The Miss Universe 2025 competition, held in Bangkok on November 21, has been marred by a series of controversies, including allegations of rigged results, health issues among contestants, and the resignation of key judges. Following these events, Melissa Queenie Sapini, who represented Haiti, has publicly called for an “independent, external, and transparent” investigation into the pageant. This call for accountability comes in the wake of Miss Universe winner Fátima Bosch's defense of the organization during a recent ABC News interview.

People MagazineMiss Haiti demands ‘transparent’ external probe into Miss Universe pageant

Melissa Sapini, 22, has emerged as a vocal critic of the Miss Universe Organization, emphasizing that her concerns extend beyond individual titles. In contrast, Fátima Bosch, who won the crown, has defended the organization amid the controversies. Sapini has made it clear that her statements are not aimed at Bosch but rather at ensuring the safety and integrity of future contestants.

Sapini's statement highlights serious allegations, including claims of predetermined finalist selections and a troubling environment during the competition. She described conditions backstage as chaotic, with contestants experiencing illness, including flu symptoms and food poisoning. Reports indicated that several contestants were hospitalized, raising questions about the pageant's management of health and safety protocols.

People Magazine

Central to Sapini's concerns is the behavior of Nawat Itsaragrisil, a pageant executive whose confrontation with Bosch during the competition has drawn significant attention. Sapini criticized Itsaragrisil's public response to the incident, stating, “His crocodile tears were dramatic, not honest,” and accused him of attempting to silence dissent through legal threats. The Miss Grand International organization, which Itsaragrisil leads, has disputed Sapini's claims, asserting that Bosch mischaracterized the confrontation.

In response to the allegations, the Miss Universe Organization has denied claims of misconduct and defended its practices. A representative for Miss Grand International stated that the organization adheres to strict food management standards and that contestants are required to submit health information in advance. However, Sapini contends that the organization failed to adequately address the health issues that arose during the competition.

People Magazine

• “Let me be clear: this is not about Fátima. This is about protecting the women who cannot safely speak for themselves. I am speaking out because the organizers continue to provide excuses instead of answers,” — Melissa Queenie Sapini, Miss Haiti 2025

People Magazine

• “ "Having Miss Universe defend Miss Universe is like asking a police department to investigate itself — it will never produce the full truth," concludes Sapini's statement.” — Melissa Queenie Sapini, Miss Haiti 2025

People Magazine

• “There were so many red flags from the beginning.” — Melissa Queenie Sapini, Miss Haiti 2025

As calls for an independent investigation grow, the future of the Miss Universe Organization hangs in the balance. Sapini's insistence on transparency reflects broader concerns about the integrity of the pageant and the well-being of its contestants. The outcome of this situation may have lasting implications for the Miss Universe brand and its operational practices.

People Magazine