Story perspectives

Defense Minister Rejects IDF Promotion Amid Protests

12/7/2025

Center

Katz Rejects Promotion

Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz rejected the IDF chief of staff's recommendation to promote a senior officer amid alleged calls for military service refusal during the 2023 judicial overhaul protests.
Katz said the IDF must adhere to political decisions made by the government.
He criticized IDF Chief of Staff Eyal Zamir, arguing promotions should follow the established process.
Katz asserted the defense minister's role is to enforce political directives.

Left

Giltman Defends Promotion

Lieutenant Colonel (Res.) German Giltman criticized Defense Minister Israel Katz for rejecting his promotion, calling it political rather than professional.
He clarified his protest movement involvement, saying he was part of "Tankers for the Defense of Israel and Democracy," not "Brothers in Arms."
He denied calling for refusal to serve and condemned such actions.
Giltman decided to remain as division chief of staff, stressing his desire to stay above politics.

1 of 2

Katz Rejects Promotion

Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz rejected the IDF chief of staff's recommendation to promote a senior officer amid alleged calls for military service refusal during the 2023 judicial overhaul protests.
Katz said the IDF must adhere to political decisions made by the government.
He criticized IDF Chief of Staff Eyal Zamir, arguing promotions should follow the established process.
Katz asserted the defense minister's role is to enforce political directives.

1 / 2