Full Breakdown
MLS Commissioner Don Garber Softens Stance on Promotion and Relegation
12/5/2025, 8:19:01 PM
Evolving Perspectives on Promotion and Relegation
During his annual State of the League address, MLS Commissioner Don Garber acknowledged a shift in his previously firm stance against the concept of promotion and relegation within Major League Soccer (MLS). While he emphasized that the league is not ready to implement such a system, he stated, “There’s no real point of saying never because I don’t know what the future would look like.” This marks a notable departure from his earlier dismissals of the idea, which he deemed incompatible with the American soccer landscape.
Garber highlighted the significant investments made by club owners in stadiums and training facilities as a reason for maintaining the current closed structure of MLS. He noted that the league has experienced a 15% increase in revenue compared to 2024, along with a 30% rise in regular-season viewership and a 23% increase during the playoffs. These metrics underscore the league's growth and stability, which Garber attributes to the existing framework.
Future Possibilities and Current Limitations
Garber pointed to the ongoing development of lower divisions in U.S. soccer as a potential factor that could influence the future viability of a promotion and relegation system. He stated, “Maybe as the development of the lower divisions continues to grow, there will be a proper ecosystem,” although he expressed skepticism about the current capacity for such a system to exist.
The commissioner also discussed the league's strategic overhaul, termed "MLS 3.0," which includes plans for new stadiums in cities like Chicago, Miami, and New York, as well as a transition to a summer-to-spring season starting in 2027. This shift aims to align MLS more closely with international soccer standards.
Challenges in Vancouver
Garber's remarks were not without concern, particularly regarding the Vancouver Whitecaps. The team's lease at BC Place is set to expire, and progress on securing a new stadium has stalled. Garber expressed frustration over the lack of support from local government, stating, “What we have there has to change. And right now, we're not necessarily on a path to do that.” He indicated that if the situation does not improve, the league may need to make difficult decisions regarding the franchise.
Criticism and Opposition
Despite Garber's cautious optimism, there are dissenting voices within the soccer community. Some critics argue that the introduction of promotion and relegation could destabilize the league, particularly for teams like Toronto FC, which have struggled in recent seasons. The potential for relegation raises concerns among fans and stakeholders about the long-term viability of their clubs.
Official Statements & Responses
Garber reiterated that while he is open to the idea of promotion and relegation in the future, it is not imminent. He emphasized the importance of maintaining a stable environment for the league's growth and success. “I’ve learned never say never. That doesn’t mean we’re having promotion/relegation anytime soon,” he stated.
What's Next
As MLS prepares for its transition to a new calendar and continues to expand its reach, the conversation around promotion and relegation will likely persist. The league's ability to adapt to changing circumstances, as evidenced by its renegotiated media partnership with Apple, will be crucial in shaping its future direction. The introduction of a promotion and relegation system in U.S. soccer is also on the horizon, with the USL planning to implement it by the 2027-28 season, further complicating the landscape for MLS.
