Full Breakdown
Controversy Erupts Over Anti-ICE Nativity Scene at St. Susanna Parish
12/7/2025, 3:48:40 AM
Nativity Scene Sparks Debate
St. Susanna Parish in Dedham, Massachusetts, has ignited controversy with its nativity scene featuring a sign that reads "ICE was here," replacing the traditional figures of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph. This display, installed on November 29, is intended to protest the actions of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and highlight the plight of immigrant families. Father Stephen Josoma, the parish priest, stated that the display aims to reflect the current humanitarian issues faced by immigrants, particularly those from countries like Honduras, Guatemala, and Afghanistan.
Archdiocese's Response
The Archdiocese of Boston has condemned the display, labeling it "divisive political messaging." Terrence Donilon, a spokesperson for the Archdiocese, emphasized that the church's norms prohibit the use of sacred objects for purposes other than worship. He stated, "The display should be removed, and the manger restored to its proper sacred purpose." The Archdiocese also noted that St. Susanna did not seek permission for the display, which they argue detracts from genuine opportunities for prayer and worship.
Support and Criticism from Parishioners
Despite the Archdiocese's condemnation, many parishioners have expressed their support for Father Josoma and the message of the nativity scene. Some attendees at recent masses voiced their discontent with the Archdiocese's stance, arguing that the church should take a more active role in advocating for immigrants. One parishioner remarked, "I’m also upset that our church doesn’t stand up for the immigrants in a stronger and more vocal way."
Conversely, critics, including C.J. Doyle, head of the Catholic Action League, have labeled the display as "sacrilegious" and accused Josoma of politicizing Christmas. Doyle stated, "He’s trivializing it and he’s using his position as a pastor to promote his left-wing political ideology."
Historical Context of the Display
This is not the first time St. Susanna's has used its nativity scene to address political issues. In previous years, the parish has tackled topics such as gun control and climate change. Notably, in 2018, the nativity featured a baby Jesus figure in a cage, protesting the Trump administration's family separation policy at the border.
Official Statements and Reactions
Father Josoma has defended the display, asserting that religious art should provoke reflection and dialogue about pressing social issues. He stated, "How we treat the least among us is how we ultimately treat Christ." The display has also drawn criticism from ICE officials, with Acting Director Todd Lyons calling it "abhorrent" and suggesting it contributes to a dangerous narrative against law enforcement.
What's Next for St. Susanna Parish
A parish council meeting is scheduled to discuss the future of the nativity scene, with Father Josoma indicating he will consult with the council before making any decisions. The ongoing debate reflects broader tensions within the Catholic community regarding the intersection of faith and social justice issues, particularly concerning immigration policies in the United States.
