Seymour Hersh: A Documentary on the Legacy of Investigative Journalism

"Cover-Up," a documentary directed by Laura Poitras and Mark Obenhaus, chronicles the life and career of investigative journalist Seymour Hersh. The film highlights Hersh's significant contributions to journalism, particularly his exposé of the My Lai massacre during the Vietnam War, which challenged the U.S. Army's official narrative and influenced public opinion against the war. The documentary premiered at the Venice Film Festival in September 2025, where it received an emotional response from the audience, moving Hersh to tears.

The Guardian

Hersh, now 88 years old, reflects on the current state of journalism, expressing concern over the decline of traditional news outlets and the rise of self-publishing platforms like Substack. He notes that while these platforms allow for editorial freedom, they lack the visibility and credibility of established media. "There are no gatekeepers on information any more," Obenhaus states, emphasizing the challenges faced by journalists in a fragmented media landscape. Hersh himself has turned to Substack, where he maintains a dedicated readership, but he acknowledges the differences compared to writing for major newspapers like the New York Times.

The Guardian

The documentary paints a vivid picture of Hersh as a contentious figure, often at odds with both editorial offices and political leaders. An unearthed tape reveals President Nixon referring to Hersh as "a son of a bitch" but also acknowledging his accuracy. Hersh's collaboration with Poitras was initially fraught with tension; he was reluctant to participate and threatened to quit the project. Poitras, known for her work on the Edward Snowden documentary "Citizenfour," navigated these challenges, ultimately capturing Hersh's complex character on film.

The Guardian

"Cover-Up" critiques the inherent contradictions within the media industry, suggesting that while editors claim to seek impactful stories, they often shy away from the risks associated with them. Hersh's career exemplifies this struggle, as he notes that investigative reporting is frequently a thankless endeavor. He reflects on the importance of journalism in holding power accountable, stating, "The principle of journalism is incredible... journalism matters."

The Guardian

The premiere of "Cover-Up" elicited a strong emotional reaction from the audience, highlighting Hersh's status as a "lone-wolf troublemaker" in journalism. Poitras remarked on the unexpected recognition Hersh received, while he himself expressed discomfort with the prolonged applause, indicating his complex relationship with public acclaim.

The Guardian

"Cover-Up" serves as both a tribute to Seymour Hersh's legacy and a commentary on the evolving landscape of journalism. It underscores the vital role of investigative reporting in society while acknowledging the challenges faced by journalists today. As Hersh continues to write and engage with his audience, the documentary invites reflection on the future of journalism in an era marked by rapid change and uncertainty.

The Guardian