Story perspectives

Tribunal Backs Nurse's Harassment Claim Against NHS Fife

12/8/2025

Summary

Story summary

The tribunal upheld Nurse Sandie Peggie's harassment claim against NHS Fife over sharing a changing room with Dr. Beth Upton, while dismissing her allegations against Upton and NHS Fife.
Judge Sandy Kemp noted that the supreme court ruling on biological sex was not definitive for changing room policies.
Peggie expressed relief at the ruling, while gender critical advocates criticized the lack of clarity for employers.
NHS Fife acknowledged the case's complexity and said it aims to maintain an inclusive environment.
A hearing for Peggie's compensation will be scheduled later.

1 of 1

Story summary

The tribunal upheld Nurse Sandie Peggie's harassment claim against NHS Fife over sharing a changing room with Dr. Beth Upton, while dismissing her allegations against Upton and NHS Fife.
Judge Sandy Kemp noted that the supreme court ruling on biological sex was not definitive for changing room policies.
Peggie expressed relief at the ruling, while gender critical advocates criticized the lack of clarity for employers.
NHS Fife acknowledged the case's complexity and said it aims to maintain an inclusive environment.
A hearing for Peggie's compensation will be scheduled later.