Full Breakdown
Devin Williams Signs with Mets After Lack of Yankees Offer
12/8/2025, 9:00:49 PM
Yankees' Decision on Devin Williams
Devin Williams, a former relief pitcher for the New York Yankees, has signed a three-year, $51 million contract with the New York Mets after a disappointing season in pinstripes. Yankees General Manager Brian Cashman confirmed that the team did not extend a formal offer to Williams, despite having communicated with his agent about keeping the Yankees informed on his market status. Cashman noted that Williams' camp never reached out to discuss a potential return to the Yankees before he finalized his deal with the Mets.
Williams' tenure with the Yankees was marked by struggles, including a 4.79 ERA, which led to him losing the closer's role twice during the season. Cashman acknowledged that while Williams had a challenging year, he believed the reliever's performance was better than his statistics indicated. Williams expressed optimism about his new role with the Mets, stating he is open to contributing in any capacity to help the team pursue a World Series title.
Background on Williams' Performance
Before joining the Yankees, Williams was recognized as one of the top relief pitchers in Major League Baseball, having been named the 2020 National League Rookie of the Year and a two-time All-Star during his time with the Milwaukee Brewers. His previous seasons included impressive statistics, such as a sub-2.00 ERA in four of five full seasons. However, his 2025 season with the Yankees did not meet expectations, leading to speculation about his future with the team.
Criticism of Yankees' Bullpen Strategy
The Yankees' bullpen performance in 2025 was subpar, with a collective 4.37 ERA, ranking among the worst in the league. Following Williams' departure, analysts have suggested that the Yankees must prioritize acquiring new relief pitchers to strengthen their bullpen. The team has been relatively inactive in the offseason, prompting calls for them to target free agents who can fill the gaps left by Williams and others.
Official Statements & Responses
Brian Cashman stated, “I would agree that his season was better than how the normal numbers look. I would agree he had a handful of games that destroyed the overall numbers.” He emphasized that the Yankees were not eager to bring Williams back after his lackluster performance.
What's Next for the Yankees
With Williams now off the market, the Yankees are under pressure to explore other free agent options to bolster their bullpen. Potential targets include Shawn Armstrong, who had a strong season with the Texas Rangers, and Tyler Rogers, known for his consistency. The Yankees will need to act quickly to ensure they remain competitive in the upcoming season.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
While Cashman confirmed that the Yankees did not make a formal offer to Williams, the specifics of the communication between the Yankees and Williams' camp remain unclear. There is also uncertainty regarding the Mets' plans for Williams, particularly if Edwin Diaz will return as the closer.
Verbatim Quotes
“Bringing him back, I wouldn’t have made the phone call if it wasn’t a possibility, but we didn’t make an offer.” — Brian Cashman, General Manager, New York Yankees
“open to pitching in whatever role the team needs him for and wants to win a World Series in New York,” — Devin Williams, Pitcher, New York Mets
