Story perspectives

Protests Erupt Over Religious Discrimination at OU University

12/9/2025

Summary

Fulnecky Sparks Protests

Protests erupted at the University of Oklahoma over a grading dispute involving Samantha Fulnecky, a University of Oklahoma student.
Fulnecky claims religious discrimination, prompting supporters to rally for reinstating graduate instructor Mel Curth.
The university said Fulnecky's zero on an essay citing the Bible regarding gender won't affect her final score.
The Graduate Student Senate has called for stronger protections for instructors amid ongoing investigations.

Summary

Instructors Face Backlash

Two University of Oklahoma instructors were placed on administrative leave amid protests over grading and viewpoint discrimination.
Graduate student instructor Mel Curth gave a failing grade to Samantha Fulnecky for an essay calling transgender identities 'demonic'.
After Curth's suspension, Kelli Alvarez reportedly excused students attending a protest supporting Curth but not counter-protesters.
The university condemned Alvarez's actions as inappropriate and urged neutrality in the classroom amid debate on academic freedom.

History

Historical Context

The 1967 Land O'Lakes Statement established principles for academic freedom in Catholic universities, advocating for autonomy from external authority. This followed significant events like the 1965 St. John's University dismissal of professors for diverging views. Today, ongoing disputes over grading and viewpoint discrimination, as seen with instructors Mel Curth and Kelli Alvarez, reflect the enduring relevance of these principles in shaping educational policies.

1 of 3

Fulnecky Sparks Protests

Protests erupted at the University of Oklahoma over a grading dispute involving Samantha Fulnecky, a University of Oklahoma student.
Fulnecky claims religious discrimination, prompting supporters to rally for reinstating graduate instructor Mel Curth.
The university said Fulnecky's zero on an essay citing the Bible regarding gender won't affect her final score.
The Graduate Student Senate has called for stronger protections for instructors amid ongoing investigations.

1 / 3