Full Breakdown
Controversial Nativity Scene at Dedham Church Sparks Debate Over Immigration Policies
12/9/2025, 7:52:04 AM
Nativity Scene with Anti-ICE Message
A Nativity display outside St. Susanna Parish in Dedham, Massachusetts, has ignited controversy due to its anti-Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) message. The display, which replaces the figures of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph with a sign reading "ICE WAS HERE," was installed shortly after Thanksgiving. The sign implies that the Holy Family has been detained by ICE, reflecting ongoing concerns about immigration enforcement in the Boston area. The display also includes a note stating, “The Holy Family is safe in the Sanctuary of our Church,” along with a phone number for LUCE, an immigrant advocacy group that monitors ICE activities.
Church's Intent and Response
Father Stephen Josoma, the pastor of St. Susanna Parish, stated that the intention behind the display was to evoke dialogue about contemporary issues surrounding immigration. He emphasized that the church aims to reflect on current humanitarian crises, asserting, “Some do not agree with our message, but that does not render our display sacrilegious.” The church has a history of using its Nativity scenes to comment on social issues, including gun violence and climate change.
Archdiocese's Opposition
The Archdiocese of Boston has condemned the display, calling it "divisive political messaging" and asserting that it violates church norms regarding the use of sacred objects. In a statement, the Archdiocese emphasized that churchgoers should encounter genuine opportunities for prayer and worship, not political statements. The Archdiocese also noted that St. Susanna Parish did not seek permission for the display, which they argue should be removed to restore the Nativity scene's sacred purpose.
Criticism and Support
Critics of the display, including C.J. Doyle, executive director of the Catholic Action League of Massachusetts, labeled it a "publicity seeking, dissident" act that politicizes Christmas. Conversely, many parishioners and local residents have expressed support for the display, viewing it as a necessary commentary on the treatment of immigrants. Some argue that the message aligns with the teachings of Jesus, who they believe would advocate for compassion towards marginalized communities.
Official Statements and Reactions
Todd Lyons, acting director of ICE, condemned the display, stating that it contributes to a dangerous narrative that has led to increased assaults on ICE officers. He praised the Archdiocese for its stance against what he termed an extremist narrative. Meanwhile, local supporters of the display argue that it reflects the church's commitment to social justice and humanitarian issues.
What's Next?
As of now, Father Josoma has indicated that he will discuss the future of the Nativity scene with Archbishop Richard Henning before making any decisions. The ongoing dialogue surrounding this display highlights the broader tensions between religious expression and political activism within the context of immigration policy in the United States.
