Story perspectives

Supreme Court Weighs Trump's Power to Dismiss Agency Heads

12/9/2025

Center

Trump's Removal Authority

The Supreme Court is deciding whether U.S. President Donald Trump may remove heads of independent agencies, including Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter.
The administration argues that at-will removal ensures executive accountability.
Liberal justices warn the move could disrupt the balance of power and a century of agency independence.
Conservative justices hesitate about unchecked power, particularly over the Federal Reserve.
A ruling is anticipated by summer 2026.

Right

Trump's Tariff Strategy

U.S. President Donald Trump plans to maintain his tariff program despite Supreme Court limits on presidential emergency powers.
U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer says alternative legal tools have existed for years to keep tariffs effective.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent says they will rely on trade laws to impose duties on national-security grounds.
The steps reassure stakeholders and align with the National Security Strategy, which links economic security to national security.

History

Historical Context

The 1935 Supreme Court ruling in Schechter Poultry Corp. v. United States limited executive power by declaring parts of the National Industrial Recovery Act unconstitutional, emphasizing agency independence. This decision reflected ongoing tensions between executive authority and institutional autonomy, a debate that resurfaces today regarding President Trump's power to remove agency heads, potentially reshaping the balance of power in U.S. governance.

1 of 3

Trump's Removal Authority

The Supreme Court is deciding whether U.S. President Donald Trump may remove heads of independent agencies, including Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter.
The administration argues that at-will removal ensures executive accountability.
Liberal justices warn the move could disrupt the balance of power and a century of agency independence.
Conservative justices hesitate about unchecked power, particularly over the Federal Reserve.
A ruling is anticipated by summer 2026.

1 / 3