Full Breakdown
Gadsden County Jury Awards $779 Million in Internet Cafe Death Case
12/10/2025, 8:40:53 PM
Jury Verdict and Implications
On December 9, 2025, a Gadsden County jury awarded a $779 million verdict to the family of Lewis Butler, a security guard killed during an attempted robbery at an internet gambling cafe in Havana, Florida. The wrongful death lawsuit claimed that the cafe's owners, Fortune MGT 2023 LLC and Manishkumar Patel, failed to report a prior robbery and neglected known security risks. This verdict is reportedly the largest in Gadsden County history and is seen as a significant step towards accountability for the operations of internet gambling cafes, which have been criticized for attracting criminal activity.
Background of the Incident
Lewis Butler was shot eight times while attempting to protect a cashier during the robbery in November 2023. The assailant, Kevontae Washington, was convicted of first-degree murder and other charges related to the incident. The case highlighted the dangers associated with internet gambling cafes, which have been a contentious issue in Florida for over a decade. Despite legislative efforts to regulate these establishments, they continue to operate, often in strip malls, presenting challenges for law enforcement.
Legal Proceedings and Testimonies
Civil rights attorney Ben Crump, representing Butler's family, emphasized the importance of the verdict in providing compensation for the family's loss and in advocating for the closure of internet gambling cafes. Crump noted that the shooting could have been prevented if the cafe had reported previous robberies. Testimonies during the trial revealed that a gun stolen during an earlier robbery was used in Butler's murder, further underscoring the negligence of the cafe's management.
Criticism of Internet Gambling Cafes
The operations of internet gambling cafes have faced scrutiny due to their association with illegal gambling and criminal activities. Florida's attempts to regulate these cafes began in 2013, following a crackdown on similar establishments. However, enforcement has proven difficult, as penalties for operating such cafes are often misdemeanors, allowing offenders to quickly relocate and continue their operations elsewhere. The ongoing presence of these cafes raises concerns among local authorities regarding public safety.
Official Statements & Responses
Crump expressed determination to secure compensation for Butler's family, stating, "We may have to attach garnishments and liens to property and bank accounts, but we are dogmatic in pursuit of making sure we get compensation from those who the jury felt were responsible for this unnecessary, tragic death." The case has reignited discussions about the regulation of internet gambling cafes and their impact on community safety.
What's Next
The substantial verdict may prompt further scrutiny of internet gambling operations in Florida, potentially leading to renewed legislative efforts to enforce stricter regulations. The Butler family's case could serve as a catalyst for change, as they advocate for the closure of these establishments to prevent future tragedies.
