Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Catherine Hoggle Declared Competent for 2014 Murders Trial

12/11/2025

24 4 Full Breakdown

Summary

Story summary

Catherine Hoggle has been declared competent to stand trial for the murders of Sarah and Jacob, who disappeared in 2014.
Judge James Bonifant issued ruling on December 10, 2025.
Two psychiatrists testified, with one saying Hoggle remains delusional and the other that her mental state improved.
Prosecutors presented evidence showing Hoggle understands the charges.
A status hearing is scheduled for December 23 and a trial is anticipated in late 2026.

History

Historical Context

The 1992 Supreme Court ruling in *Foucha v. Louisiana* established that individuals found not guilty by reason of insanity must be mentally competent for continued confinement, influencing legal standards for mental health evaluations. This decision reflects a historical trend in U.S. law, balancing mental health considerations with accountability, as seen in ongoing cases like Catherine Hoggle's, where her competency is under review.

1 of 2

Story summary

Catherine Hoggle has been declared competent to stand trial for the murders of Sarah and Jacob, who disappeared in 2014.
Judge James Bonifant issued ruling on December 10, 2025.
Two psychiatrists testified, with one saying Hoggle remains delusional and the other that her mental state improved.
Prosecutors presented evidence showing Hoggle understands the charges.
A status hearing is scheduled for December 23 and a trial is anticipated in late 2026.

1 / 2