Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Joy Reid Sparks Debate on Jingle Bells' Racist Roots

12/12/2025

33 6 Full Breakdown

Summary

Story summary

Joy Reid reposted a video claiming Jingle Bells is racist and linked to minstrel shows.
The video argues composer James Lord Pierpont wrote the song to mock Black people.
Critics say Reid oversimplifies historical research, while supporters argue that examining cultural origins is vital.
The reposting has drawn attention to the politicization of Christmas traditions.

History

Historical Context

James Lord Pierpont composed "Jingle Bells" in 1857, originally titled "One Horse Open Sleigh," as a secular winter song. Although it was first performed in Boston, it gained popularity as a Christmas song in the 1860s. The ongoing debate about its cultural significance reflects broader discussions on representation and appropriation in holiday traditions, influencing how future generations celebrate Christmas.

1 of 2

Story summary

Joy Reid reposted a video claiming Jingle Bells is racist and linked to minstrel shows.
The video argues composer James Lord Pierpont wrote the song to mock Black people.
Critics say Reid oversimplifies historical research, while supporters argue that examining cultural origins is vital.
The reposting has drawn attention to the politicization of Christmas traditions.

1 / 2