The Evolution of Managerial Roles in Major League Baseball: A Focus on Pat Murphy and Stephen Vogt

In 2024, Pat Murphy and Stephen Vogt were awarded Manager of the Year, marking a significant achievement as they became the second managers in each league to win the award consecutively. Both managers have been pivotal in transforming their respective small-market teams into division winners. As of 2025, Murphy's contract with the Milwaukee Brewers is set to expire after the 2026 season, mirroring the situation faced by former manager Craig Counsell, who left for the Chicago Cubs after securing a lucrative five-year deal worth $40 million. In contrast, Vogt's contract status remains less precarious, as he is not considered a lame duck.

ESPN

Under Murphy's leadership, the Brewers achieved the best record in Major League Baseball during the regular season but were ultimately swept in the National League Championship Series by the Los Angeles Dodgers, who went on to win the World Series. Murphy expressed gratitude for his position, stating, "I'm lucky to have a major league job. I really am. I owe a lot to the Milwaukee Brewers. I really do. I hope they want me." His managerial style blends traditional baseball wisdom with modern analytics, emphasizing collaboration and trust among players and staff.

ESPN

The role of a Major League Baseball manager has evolved significantly over the past three decades. Managers now serve as extensions of their teams' front offices, tasked with implementing organizational strategies at the major league level. This shift has resulted in a growing emphasis on analytics and data-driven decision-making, which has changed the perception of managers from mere game-day strategists to multifaceted leaders. Despite this evolution, managerial salaries have not kept pace with those of coaches in other major sports leagues. For instance, Counsell's $8 million annual salary is substantially lower than that of top NFL and NBA coaches, such as Kansas City Chiefs coach Andy Reid, who earns $20 million.

ESPN

While Murphy and Vogt's successes are notable, there is ongoing debate regarding the compensation and recognition of MLB managers compared to their counterparts in other sports. Critics argue that the disparity in salaries reflects a lack of appreciation for the complexities of the managerial role in baseball, especially as managers navigate the intricacies of player dynamics and front office expectations.

ESPN

• “I found a home. If I do it 10 more years, you know, I'd like to do it in Milwaukee.” — Pat Murphy, Manager of the Milwaukee Brewers

ESPN

• “It ain't about me. That's something that I'm so lucky that I've discovered late in this thing. If you take yourself out of it and focus on what's best for everybody, then you'll tend to collaborate. Then you'll tend to be more flexible, more open-minded. And that's just what I've adopted.” — Pat Murphy, reflecting on his managerial philosophy.

ESPN

As Major League Baseball continues to evolve, the roles of managers like Pat Murphy and Stephen Vogt exemplify the blend of traditional and modern approaches necessary for success. Their experiences highlight the ongoing transformation within the sport, where managerial effectiveness is increasingly measured by adaptability and collaboration rather than solely by in-game decisions.

ESPN