Full Breakdown
Fantasy Football Tight End Start/Sit Decisions for Week 15
12/13/2025, 4:34:45 AM
Overview of Key Tight Ends
As fantasy football playoffs approach, managers face critical decisions regarding tight end lineups. This week, Dalton Kincaid of the Buffalo Bills, Dalton Schultz of the Houston Texans, and Mark Andrews of the Baltimore Ravens are among the key players under consideration. Each presents unique matchups and performance trends that could influence their fantasy output.
Dalton Kincaid's Rising Profile
Dalton Kincaid has emerged as a significant contributor for the Buffalo Bills, particularly after returning from injury. In Week 14, he recorded five targets, converting them into four catches for 41 yards and a touchdown against the Cincinnati Bengals. Kincaid has demonstrated strong chemistry with quarterback Josh Allen, leading all Bills tight ends in routes run. Despite limited playing time—34% of offensive snaps—he has scored at least 14 PPR points in five of his nine healthy games this season. Kincaid's matchup against the New England Patriots, who rank ninth in fantasy points allowed to tight ends, positions him as a mid-range TE1 with substantial scoring potential.
Dalton Schultz's Steady Performance
Dalton Schultz has been a reliable option for the Houston Texans, maintaining a consistent floor with at least five catches in eight of his eleven starts this season. However, his recent performance has been less impressive, with only one touchdown to date. Facing the Arizona Cardinals, who rank 26th against tight ends, Schultz is expected to have a reasonable matchup. Nevertheless, his lack of scoring and recent low outputs may limit his appeal compared to Kincaid.
Mark Andrews' Favorable Matchup
Mark Andrews of the Baltimore Ravens enters Week 15 with a favorable matchup against the Cincinnati Bengals, who have struggled defensively against tight ends. The Bengals have allowed the most catches, yards, and touchdowns to the position this season. Despite recent struggles, Andrews remains a reliable red-zone threat, having scored five touchdowns this year. His performance against the Bengals earlier this season was underwhelming, but the current matchup suggests he could rebound significantly.
Criticism of Tight End Options
While Kincaid, Schultz, and Andrews are highlighted as potential starters, there are concerns regarding their consistency. Critics point to Kincaid's limited snap count as a potential risk, while Schultz's lack of touchdowns raises questions about his ceiling. Andrews, despite his favorable matchup, has been outperformed by teammate Isaiah Likely in recent games, which could impact his target share.
Official Statements & Responses
Buffalo Bills head coach Sean McDermott expressed confidence in Kincaid's health and readiness for the upcoming game, indicating that he has fully recovered from his previous injuries. Meanwhile, the Ravens' coaching staff acknowledges Andrews' importance in the offense, particularly in high-stakes matchups against weak defenses.
Verbatim Quotes
- “Kincaid has been the Bills’ best receiving option this year when on the field.” — Fantasy Analyst
- “The Bengals have allowed the most catches, yards, touchdowns, and fantasy points per game to tight ends, and the gap between them and the next-worst team isn’t close.” — Fantasy Expert
Conclusion
As fantasy managers finalize their lineups for Week 15, Dalton Kincaid, Dalton Schultz, and Mark Andrews present varying degrees of risk and reward. Kincaid's potential for high-scoring plays, Schultz's steady but low ceiling, and Andrews' favorable matchup against a weak defense make them all worthy of consideration. Ultimately, the decision will hinge on individual team needs and the specific dynamics of each matchup.
