Story perspectives

Tennessee Judge Certifies Bail Law Challenge for Inmates

12/13/2025

Center

Inmates Challenge Bail

A federal judge in Tennessee certified a class of Shelby County jail inmates in a suit challenging state bail laws.
The lawsuit, brought by Just City, argues the bail law prevents judges from considering a defendant's finances and violates due process and equal protection.
In Oklahoma, a judge allowed a wrongful termination suit against former state schools Superintendent Ryan Walters to proceed after Janessa Bointy advocated for mental health resources.

Right

Judge Overturns Verdict

Judge Sarah West in Minnesota overturned a unanimous jury verdict in a $7.2 million Medicaid fraud case, raising concerns about prosecuting white-collar crime.
Legal experts, including University of Minnesota law professor JaneAnne Murray, said such reversals are rare.
Republican Senator Michael Holmstrom labeled the ruling unprecedented and demanded transparency about the case records.
Washoe County Judge dismissed the Nieto family’s lawsuit against a jail-communication company, citing legal technicalities.

History

Historical Context

The 1972 Supreme Court ruling in *Argersinger v. Hamlin* established the right to counsel as fundamental in criminal cases, influencing subsequent bail laws. Despite this, modern practices still imprison individuals for unpaid debts, echoing historical injustices. Just City’s lawsuit against Tennessee's bail laws highlights ongoing challenges to fair legal representation and due process, potentially reshaping defendants' rights across the U.S.

1 of 3

Inmates Challenge Bail

A federal judge in Tennessee certified a class of Shelby County jail inmates in a suit challenging state bail laws.
The lawsuit, brought by Just City, argues the bail law prevents judges from considering a defendant's finances and violates due process and equal protection.
In Oklahoma, a judge allowed a wrongful termination suit against former state schools Superintendent Ryan Walters to proceed after Janessa Bointy advocated for mental health resources.

1 / 3