Dolphins Coach Mike McDaniel Contemplates Quarterback Change After Playoff Elimination

Following the Miami Dolphins' 28-15 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers, which eliminated them from playoff contention, head coach Mike McDaniel is considering a change at the quarterback position. Tua Tagovailoa's performance has come under scrutiny, as he completed 22 of 28 passes for 253 yards, two touchdowns, and one interception. However, his effectiveness was questioned, particularly as he only managed 65 passing yards through three quarters, with both touchdowns occurring when the Dolphins were trailing significantly.

CBS SportsBleacher ReportDolphins head coach Mike McDaniel considering benching Tua TagovailoaESPNBleacher ReportEssentiallySportsMiami Herald

McDaniel stated, "The quarterback play last night was not good enough, and so for me, everything's on the table," indicating that he is open to exploring alternatives. He has two potential replacements: Zach Wilson, the former second overall pick, and rookie Quinn Ewers, who has served primarily as an emergency quarterback this season. McDaniel emphasized the need for improved performance at the quarterback position, noting that "there's no one entitled to preferential treatment."

ESPN

Tagovailoa, who signed a four-year, $212.4 million extension in 2024, has struggled this season, leading the league with 15 interceptions and ranking 30th in QBR. His passer rating has dropped to 88.5, down from over 100 in previous seasons. Despite his past successes, including leading the NFL in passing yards in 2023, his recent form has raised questions about his future with the team.

CBS Sports

The financial implications of benching or releasing Tagovailoa are significant. If the Dolphins were to cut him, they would incur a staggering $99.2 million in dead cap, making it a challenging decision. Keeping him would result in a $56.4 million cap hit for the next season. McDaniel acknowledged the complexity of the situation, stating, "It’s always what gives us the best chance to win the game."

EssentiallySports

Critics argue that benching Tagovailoa may not be the solution, as McDaniel himself has pointed out that multiple factors contribute to the team's struggles. He noted that the entire team, including coaching staff, must improve, suggesting that the blame should not rest solely on the quarterback. Dolphins insider Joe Schad remarked that while a change may seem reasonable, McDaniel might feel compelled to continue starting Tagovailoa if his job security is uncertain.

Miami Herald

As the Dolphins prepare to face the Cincinnati Bengals, McDaniel is expected to make a decision regarding the starting quarterback. He has indicated that he will provide clarity on the situation soon, as the team seeks to finish the season on a positive note despite their playoff elimination. The outcome of this decision could have lasting implications for both Tagovailoa's career and McDaniel's future with the Dolphins.

Miami Herald

• "The QB play last night was not good enough, and everything is on the table." — Mike McDaniel, Head Coach

ESPN

• "There’s no one entitled to preferential treatment." — Mike McDaniel, Head Coach

Miami Herald

• "If that’s something that disappoints him, I can understand that." — Mike McDaniel, Head Coach

Miami Herald

In summary, the Dolphins are at a crossroads with their quarterback situation, and McDaniel's upcoming decision will be pivotal for the team's future direction.

Miami Herald