Story perspectives

Indonesia's Minister Criticizes Malaysia's Aid, Sparks Outrage

12/17/2025

Center

Karnavian's Controversial Remarks

Tito Karnavian, Indonesia's Home Affairs Minister, faced backlash after saying Malaysia's 500 tonnes of humanitarian aid was "not much" compared with Indonesia's resources.
The remarks, made on a podcast, drew criticism in Malaysia and underscored a sensitive relationship between the two countries.
Malaysian voices stressed that, despite limited monetary value, the aid matters for relief.
Meanwhile, Indonesia has mobilized resources, including funding and rescue teams, to address flooding in northern Sumatra since late November.

Right

Acehnese Residents Demand Aid

Residents of Aceh, Indonesia, urge their government to permit entry of 500 tonnes of humanitarian aid from Malaysia as severe floods persist nearly three weeks.
The aid is donated by Acehnese communities in Malaysia.
The aid entry is blocked by administrative issues and the absence of a national emergency declaration.
The floods have caused extensive damage, including a major bridge in Bireuen regency and hundreds of villages cut off.

1 of 2

Karnavian's Controversial Remarks

Tito Karnavian, Indonesia's Home Affairs Minister, faced backlash after saying Malaysia's 500 tonnes of humanitarian aid was "not much" compared with Indonesia's resources.
The remarks, made on a podcast, drew criticism in Malaysia and underscored a sensitive relationship between the two countries.
Malaysian voices stressed that, despite limited monetary value, the aid matters for relief.
Meanwhile, Indonesia has mobilized resources, including funding and rescue teams, to address flooding in northern Sumatra since late November.

1 / 2