Story perspectives

Saban and Meyer Challenge Group of Five CFP Inclusion

12/19/2025

Summary

Story summary

Nick Saban and Urban Meyer oppose including James Madison and Tulane in the College Football Playoff, arguing the Group of Five should not displace Notre Dame.
Saban likened JMU's CFP entry to a Triple-A baseball team in the World Series and said only top-15 teams should qualify.
This year marks the first time two Group of Five teams reached the CFP, fueling debates about fairness and the playoff format.

History

Historical Context

The College Football Playoff (CFP) was established in 2014, replacing the controversial Bowl Championship Series (BCS) that had been in place since 1998. The CFP aimed to enhance competition among major conferences, allowing four teams to compete for the national title. Ongoing debates, particularly from coaches like Nick Saban and Urban Meyer, reflect tensions between Group of Five and Power Five schools over equitable representation in college athletics.

1 of 2

Story summary

Nick Saban and Urban Meyer oppose including James Madison and Tulane in the College Football Playoff, arguing the Group of Five should not displace Notre Dame.
Saban likened JMU's CFP entry to a Triple-A baseball team in the World Series and said only top-15 teams should qualify.
This year marks the first time two Group of Five teams reached the CFP, fueling debates about fairness and the playoff format.

1 / 2