Full Breakdown
Florida Woman Charged with Killing Two Ex-Husbands in Coordinated Attacks
12/19/2025, 11:13:49 PM
Overview of the Incident
Susan Avalon, a 51-year-old woman from Citrus County, Florida, has been charged with first-degree homicide after allegedly killing two of her ex-husbands in separate shootings on the same day. The incidents occurred on a Wednesday, with the first shooting taking place in Tampa and the second in Bradenton. Authorities believe the attacks were premeditated and coordinated across multiple counties.
Sequence of Events
Avalon is accused of first killing her second ex-husband in Tampa before traveling to Bradenton, where she shot her first ex-husband. The Manatee County Sheriff's Office reported that the Bradenton shooting occurred around 3 p.m. when Avalon allegedly used food from a Panera Bread restaurant as a ruse to get her ex-husband to open the door. Upon his arrival, she immediately opened fire, hitting him twice, including once in the abdomen. The victim, a 54-year-old man, later succumbed to his injuries at a local hospital.
Investigation and Evidence
Following the shooting in Bradenton, deputies discovered Avalon cleaning her vehicle with bleach and rags at her home. When questioned about her ex-husband, she reportedly asked, "Which one?" This response prompted investigators to check on her second ex-husband in Tampa, where he was found dead from multiple gunshot wounds. Surveillance footage confirmed Avalon’s movements, showing her stopping at Panera Bread and then driving to the Bradenton residence.
Background and Motive
Avalon had a history of legal issues, including a 2004 child abuse charge in Virginia, which was later dropped. She had ongoing custody disputes with her ex-husbands, including approximately $4,000 in unpaid child support to her first ex-husband. The motive behind the shootings remains unclear, although it has been suggested that her financial troubles may have played a role.
Official Statements & Responses
Manatee County Sheriff Rick Wells described the events as "brazen," emphasizing the targeted nature of the attacks. He noted that the case is unprecedented in his experience, highlighting the domestic aspect of the violence. Prosecutors are considering seeking the death penalty for Avalon, who is currently in custody.
Criticism & Opposition
Avalon's live-in boyfriend expressed concern over her recent behavior, describing it as "out of character." He reported that she had mentioned her love for him "in case something happens to her" the day before the shootings, raising questions about her mental state leading up to the incidents.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
While authorities have confirmed the sequence of events, details regarding Avalon's mental health and the exact motivations for her actions remain unclear. The investigation is ongoing, with both the Manatee County Sheriff's Office and Tampa Police Department coordinating their efforts.
What's Next
Avalon faces first-degree homicide charges in Manatee County and may face additional charges in Hillsborough County. The investigation continues as authorities work to gather more evidence and determine the full scope of her actions.
