Full Breakdown
Families of October 7 Victims Criticize Government's Inquiry Plan
12/21/2025, 8:46:56 PM
Government's Proposed Inquiry Under Scrutiny
The October Council, representing families who lost loved ones in the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack, has condemned the Israeli government's plan to establish a commission of inquiry as a "smokescreen." This criticism comes ahead of a ministerial meeting where Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is set to lead discussions on the inquiry's scope. The council argues that the proposed government-led commission lacks the independence necessary for a thorough investigation, as its mandate will be determined by Netanyahu and his cabinet, rather than an impartial state commission.
Concerns Over Accountability
Critics, including members of the October Council, assert that the government's inquiry is designed to obscure accountability for the failures that led to the attack. Rafi Ben Shitrit, whose son was killed in the assault, characterized the initiative as a continuation of "trickery and confusion," aimed at silencing criticism and evading responsibility. He emphasized the need for a state commission of inquiry to ensure transparency and prevent future tragedies. Other family members echoed this sentiment, stating that the government's approach disrespects the memory of the victims and undermines the quest for truth.
Political Reactions and Opposition
The announcement that Netanyahu will head the ministerial team has drawn sharp rebukes from opposition leaders. Yair Golan, chair of the Democrats party, accused Netanyahu of seeking an alibi rather than answers, while Benny Gantz of the Blue and White party criticized the proposed inquiry as a "blow to security" and an affront to the victims' families. Gantz's party plans to introduce a motion in the Knesset to demand a state commission of inquiry, reflecting widespread discontent with the government's handling of the situation.
Upcoming Protests and Public Sentiment
In response to the government's actions, the October Council has organized a week of protests, vowing to demonstrate outside the homes of ministers and across the country. They aim to mobilize public support for a genuine investigation into the October 7 attack, emphasizing that the truth must come to light to honor the victims and prevent future occurrences.
Conflicting Reports on Inquiry's Nature
The proposed inquiry has sparked debate over its legitimacy and potential biases. While the government argues that a state commission would lack public trust, critics fear that the inquiry will serve to absolve political leaders of responsibility. The opposition has expressed concerns that the inquiry could be manipulated to shift blame away from the government and military, particularly regarding decisions made by Netanyahu's administration since 2009.
Verbatim Quotes
- “It is a smokescreen and the direct continuation of the campaign of trolling, trickery and confusion.” — Rafi Ben Shitrit, October Council Member
- “ “I’m telling you here clearly: Whoever votes for a political whitewashing committee chooses to escape responsibility.” — Shimon Buskila, October Council Member
- “The man responsible for the greatest disaster in our history isn’t looking for answers, he’s looking for an alibi.” — Yair Golan, Democrats Party Chair
The unfolding situation highlights the deep divisions within Israeli society regarding accountability for the October 7 attack and the broader implications for governance and public trust in the wake of national tragedy.
