Hong Kong Welfare Group Reverses Policy on Donated Appliances for Fire Survivors

A Hong Kong welfare group, SideBySide, has rescinded a policy that prohibited displaced residents of the Tai Po fire from taking donated appliances and furniture when they vacate their temporary accommodations. This decision came swiftly after significant backlash from affected residents, who deemed the ban unreasonable given that the items were community donations intended for their use. The transitional housing project in question, known as Good House, is managed by SideBySide.

South China Morning Post

The controversy arose when residents expressed their frustration on social media, questioning the rationale behind the policy. One resident highlighted the inadequacy of the living space, stating, “The unit is only 150 square feet and not enough for my family of three. So, we decided to move out. But why can’t we take away the furniture and appliances that … were donated to the victims?” This sentiment reflects the broader concerns among residents regarding their rights to the items that were meant to assist them during a challenging time.

South China Morning Post

Initially, SideBySide defended its policy by stating that some appliances, including refrigerators and washing machines, were purchased with funds specifically allocated for the project. The organization indicated that it had consulted with donors and concluded that these items should remain for incoming residents. However, the group later acknowledged the residents' concerns and reversed its stance, allowing them to take certain items with them upon moving out.

South China Morning Post

The initial policy faced criticism not only from residents but also from community advocates who argued that it undermined the spirit of support and solidarity that the donations represented. Critics emphasized that the donated items were intended to aid the fire survivors, and preventing them from taking these essentials was counterproductive to their recovery.

South China Morning Post

Following the policy reversal, SideBySide is expected to engage more closely with residents and community stakeholders to ensure that future policies reflect the needs and rights of those they serve. The organization may also consider revising its guidelines regarding the management of donated items to prevent similar controversies in the future.

South China Morning Post

• “But why can’t we take away the furniture and appliances that … were donated to the victims? Can anyone tell me why?” — Tai Po Fire Survivor

South China Morning Post

• “It also said it had consulted donors and agreed that the supplies should be left for the new residents to use when they moved in, although items such as pillows, hairdryers and heaters could be taken by residents when they leave.” — SideBySide Official

South China Morning Post