The Shift Towards Cocoa Alternatives in Chocolate Production

The chocolate industry is facing significant challenges due to market volatility and ethical concerns surrounding cocoa production. Cocoa prices have experienced dramatic fluctuations, peaking at over $12,000 per ton in late 2024 before dropping more than 50% throughout 2025. This instability is largely attributed to poor agricultural conditions in Ghana and Côte d'Ivoire, the world's leading cocoa producers, which have adversely affected crop yields.

CNBC

As a result of these price pressures, companies are increasingly reformulating their products to reduce reliance on cocoa. For instance, Mondelez International, the maker of Cadbury, Milka, and Toblerone, has highlighted the volatility of cocoa prices as a potential barrier to meeting financial targets. In the U.K., Pladis, the parent company of McVitie's, has altered the composition of its Club and Penguin candy bars, requiring them to be labeled as "chocolate flavored" rather than chocolate due to reduced cocoa content. This trend is indicative of a broader movement among confectioners to incorporate alternative ingredients, such as carob, pumpkin seeds, and chickpeas, into their products.

CNBC

Massimo Sabatini, co-founder and CEO of Foreverland, notes that the shift towards cocoa alternatives is gaining traction, suggesting that "fake" chocolate may soon become commonplace in budget-friendly products. He emphasizes that chocolate's versatility allows for a wide range of applications, making it an ideal candidate for alternative formulations. Similarly, Jessica Karch, marketing manager for Planet A Foods, which produces a chocolate alternative from sunflower seeds, acknowledges the growing demand for such products, particularly in markets like China and India.

CNBC

Despite the increasing prevalence of cocoa alternatives, both Karch and Sabatini stress that these products are not intended to replace traditional chocolate but rather to fill a growing gap in the market. Natasha Linhart, CEO of Atlante, highlights that cocoa-free or fermentation-based alternatives are being integrated into various applications, including coatings and fillings, to reduce cocoa content while maintaining consumer appeal. Brands like Milka are already adapting their offerings to include products with lower cocoa intensity.

CNBC

Industry experts agree that the challenges facing cocoa supply chains are unlikely to dissipate soon. Drew Geraghty, a commodity broker at ICAP, explains that while cocoa futures prices may stabilize, the high costs associated with pure chocolate are expected to persist. This sentiment is echoed by Karch, who believes that the ongoing supply chain issues will continue to influence market dynamics.

CNBC

• "In the chocolate space there are many products... I believe the alternative chocolate will substitute this big market, while [pure chocolate bars] will be more and more a luxury product." — Massimo Sabatini, CEO of Foreverland

CNBC

• "We do believe that the issues that we see currently in the supply chain of cocoa won't go away." — Jessica Karch, Marketing Manager of Planet A Foods

CNBC

• "Cocoa-free or fermentation-based masses are increasingly being used in coatings, fillings and bakery to substitute part of the cocoa content." — Natasha Linhart, CEO of Atlante

CNBC

The chocolate industry is navigating a transformative period marked by rising cocoa prices and shifting consumer preferences towards alternatives. As manufacturers adapt to these changes, the landscape of chocolate products is likely to evolve, with cocoa alternatives becoming a more prominent feature in the market.

CNBC