Full Breakdown
Departures from Heritage Foundation Signal Turmoil in Conservative Movement
12/23/2025, 1:08:58 AM
Staff Exodus to Advancing American Freedom
More than a dozen staffers from The Heritage Foundation have departed to join Advancing American Freedom (AAF), a nonprofit founded by former Vice President Mike Pence. This shift marks a significant upheaval within Heritage, which has faced internal strife following controversies surrounding its leadership and ideological direction. The departures include key figures from Heritage’s legal and economic teams, such as John Malcolm and Richard Stern, as well as Kevin Dayaratna, the foundation's former chief statistician. The move nearly doubles the size of AAF, which aims to position itself as a central player in the conservative movement.
Background of the Turmoil
The turmoil at Heritage was exacerbated by President Kevin Roberts' defense of Tucker Carlson after the host interviewed controversial figure Nick Fuentes, known for his antisemitic views. This incident sparked backlash from within the conservative community, leading to calls for Roberts to resign. Critics, including commentator Ben Shapiro, condemned Roberts for his remarks, which they felt contributed to a rising tide of antisemitism within the right. In response to the fallout, Roberts acknowledged making a "mistake" but sought to maintain his leadership position.
Official Statements & Responses
In a statement regarding the departures, Andy Olivastro, Heritage's chief advancement officer, indicated that some staff members were terminated for "conduct inconsistent with Heritage’s mission and standards." He emphasized that the organization remains committed to its mission and that the departures would allow for a stronger team. Conversely, Pence welcomed the new hires at AAF, stating, “They bring a wealth of experience, a love of country, and a deep commitment to the Constitution and Conservative Movement that will further the cause of liberty.”
Criticism & Opposition
The staff exodus has drawn mixed reactions within the conservative movement. Donald Trump Jr. criticized the departing staffers, labeling them as "Trump-hating RINOs" and suggesting that their move to AAF reflects a broader ideological divide within the GOP. Former Heritage Vice President John Malcolm, who is now leading AAF's Edwin Meese III Institute for the Rule of Law, expressed discontent with Roberts' leadership, stating that his actions have weakened the organization's credibility and mission.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
While the departures have been framed as a significant loss for Heritage, some staff members have chosen to remain loyal to the organization. Conservative activist Robby Starbuck announced his intention to continue his role at Heritage, suggesting that the resignations may be more politically motivated than indicative of a broader crisis within the organization.
What's Next
The ongoing conflict within Heritage and the broader conservative movement raises questions about its future direction, particularly as the 2028 Republican presidential primary approaches. The ideological battles within the party may continue to shape the landscape of conservative thought and influence upcoming elections.
