Full Breakdown
Governor Kathy Hochul's Veto of Montaukett Indian Nation Recognition Bill Sparks Outrage
12/23/2025, 6:31:50 AM
Veto of Recognition Bill
New York Governor Kathy Hochul has vetoed a bill aimed at restoring state recognition to the Montaukett Indian Nation, marking her fourth rejection of similar efforts. The veto, issued late on December 22, 2025, has drawn significant backlash from tribal leaders and Democratic legislators, who argue that Hochul's decision reflects a lack of understanding of Native American history and an adherence to a controversial 1910 court ruling that declared the Montaukett tribe "disintegrated." This ruling has been criticized as discriminatory and unjust, with tribal leaders asserting that it denies their sovereignty and historical existence.
The bill had received broad bipartisan support, passing the state Assembly unanimously and the Senate with a 59-1 vote. Despite this, Hochul cited "outstanding questions and issues" regarding the Montaukett's eligibility for recognition as the basis for her veto. Sandi Brewster-Walker, executive director of the Montaukett Nation, expressed her disappointment, stating, “The governor just doesn’t get it — she lacks an understanding of Native American history and is upholding an illegal, racist ruling.”
Historical Context
The Montaukett Indian Nation, native to the Montauk area of Long Island, had its recognition stripped over a century ago due to a court ruling that deemed the tribe no longer functional. This ruling contradicted earlier assertions from federal authorities that recognized the Montaukett as an existing tribe. The tribe has since sought to restore its status, arguing that the state has failed to acknowledge the historical injustices they have faced, including the loss of land and sovereignty.
Official Statements & Responses
In her veto message, Hochul reiterated her commitment to working with the Montaukett community but maintained that the tribe had not provided sufficient documentation to support their recognition. Brewster-Walker countered this claim, asserting that the tribe had submitted all necessary information and accused the governor's office of misplacing or failing to review their documentation.
Assemblyman Tommy John Schiavoni, a fellow Democrat, criticized Hochul's decision, stating, “For years, there has been broad support for a viable solution for reinstating recognition by New York State to the Montauketts.” He vowed to continue advocating for the tribe's recognition in the upcoming legislative session.
Criticism & Opposition
The veto has been met with strong criticism from various quarters, including tribal leaders who labeled the decision "inhumane and cruel." Brewster-Walker described the governor's actions as a continuation of a historical injustice, emphasizing the emotional toll on the Montaukett community. Critics argue that Hochul's veto reflects a broader pattern of neglect towards Native American issues in New York.
What's Next
The Montaukett Indian Nation plans to continue its efforts to secure recognition, with leaders expressing determination to address the outstanding issues raised by Hochul's administration. The ongoing struggle for recognition highlights the complexities of tribal sovereignty and the historical injustices faced by Native American communities in New York.
