Story perspectives

Debate Erupts Over Cultural Gatekeeping in Online Trends

12/23/2025

Summary

Story summary

In December 2025, debates over cultural gatekeeping intensified, signaling a shift in how online trends treat historical styles.
Critics say the internet reduces rich histories to vibes and starter packs, fueling backlash against superficial knowledge.
Glenn O’Brien (late writer) is cited as a model for cultural fluency, stressing context and participation.
Graydon Carter (former Vanity Fair editor) describes editors as original gatekeepers shaping culture through informed perspectives.

1 of 1

Story summary

In December 2025, debates over cultural gatekeeping intensified, signaling a shift in how online trends treat historical styles.
Critics say the internet reduces rich histories to vibes and starter packs, fueling backlash against superficial knowledge.
Glenn O’Brien (late writer) is cited as a model for cultural fluency, stressing context and participation.
Graydon Carter (former Vanity Fair editor) describes editors as original gatekeepers shaping culture through informed perspectives.