Full Breakdown
Archbishop of York's Christmas Sermon Highlights Intimidation by Israeli Militias
12/25/2025, 10:17:59 PM
Archbishop's Experience in the Holy Land
During his Christmas Day sermon at York Minster, The Most Reverend Stephen Cottrell, the Archbishop of York, recounted feeling "intimidated" by Israeli militias during a visit to the Holy Land earlier this year. He described being stopped at multiple checkpoints and being told he could not visit Palestinian families in the occupied West Bank. Cottrell emphasized the sobering nature of witnessing the physical barriers, stating, “It was sobering to see this wall for real on my visit to the Holy Land.”
Symbolism of the Nativity Scene
Cottrell received an olive wood nativity scene from representatives of the Young Men’s Christian Association (YMCA) in Bethlehem, which depicted a “large grey wall” obstructing the three kings from reaching the stable where Mary, Joseph, and Jesus were located. This imagery served as a poignant symbol of the barriers that exist not only in the Holy Land but also in broader society.
Broader Reflection on Fear and Division
In his sermon, Cottrell reflected on the theme of fear and division, stating, “We have become fearful of each other, and especially fearful of strangers.” He urged listeners to recognize their shared humanity and warned against the dangers of erecting emotional and societal barriers. He noted that such divisions can lead to a failure to welcome those in need, including the homeless, refugees, and marginalized individuals.
Call to Action
Cottrell's message extended beyond the immediate context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He called for a dismantling of the walls—both literal and metaphorical—that separate individuals from one another. He emphasized the importance of seeing Christ in the faces of those who are vulnerable, stating, “We must find ways of balancing the needs of keeping everyone safe and yet at the same time seeing and adoring the face of Christ in the face of strangers.”
Criticism & Opposition
While Cottrell's sermon resonated with many, it also faced criticism from those who argue that his portrayal of the situation may oversimplify the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Critics contend that focusing solely on the experiences of visitors may overlook the broader historical and political context affecting both Israelis and Palestinians.
Official Statements & Responses
Cottrell's remarks have sparked discussions about the role of religious leaders in addressing social justice issues. His emphasis on compassion and understanding aligns with broader calls within the Church of England to engage more deeply with contemporary social issues.
Verbatim Quotes
- “We have become – I can think of no other way of putting it – fearful of each other and especially of strangers,” — The Most Reverend Stephen Cottrell, Archbishop of York
- “It was sobering to see this wall for real on my visit to the Holy Land,” — The Most Reverend Stephen Cottrell, Archbishop of York
- “Therefore, this Christmas and especially at Christmas, we must find ways of balancing the needs of keeping everyone safe and yet at the same time seeing and adoring the face of Christ in the face of strangers, and especially in the faces of those who are in need; and then, dismantle, tear down the walls, which in keeping strangers out, keep Christ out as well.” — The Most Reverend Stephen Cottrell, Archbishop of York
Cottrell's Christmas sermon serves as a reminder of the ongoing struggles faced by marginalized communities and the importance of fostering understanding and compassion in a divided world.
