Story perspectives

Debate Erupts Over 12-Team Playoff Format's Fairness

12/28/2025

41 6

Summary

Story summary

The College Football Playoff's expanded 12-team format has not settled debates over team qualification.
Critics, including Urban Meyer, former college football coach, contend admitting Group of 5 schools like Tulane University and James Madison University creates uncompetitive matchups.
He argues fairness for smaller programs is not the aim, and the playoff's purpose is to crown a champion.
The discussions reveal the balance between competitive integrity and opportunities for smaller programs.

1 of 1

Story summary

The College Football Playoff's expanded 12-team format has not settled debates over team qualification.
Critics, including Urban Meyer, former college football coach, contend admitting Group of 5 schools like Tulane University and James Madison University creates uncompetitive matchups.
He argues fairness for smaller programs is not the aim, and the playoff's purpose is to crown a champion.
The discussions reveal the balance between competitive integrity and opportunities for smaller programs.