Story perspectives

Referee Defends Controversial No-Penalty Call in United Match

12/28/2025

Summary

Story summary

Keith Hackett, former Premier League referee, defended the decision not to award a penalty for Lisandro Martinez's handball during Manchester United's match against Newcastle United.
Pundit Gary Neville suggested Martinez's positioning before the incident influenced the decision.
After the match, United's coach Ruben Amorim praised Martinez's character, noting he handles pressure despite concerns about his size against taller opponents.
The incident raises questions about VAR's effectiveness in critical situations.

History

Historical Context

In 2012, the International Football Association Board (IFAB) approved Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology to enhance officiating accuracy in football, following years of debate and criticism over refereeing errors. The 2010 World Cup highlighted the need for such technology, particularly after Frank Lampard's disallowed goal. As VAR's implementation continues, its effectiveness and impact on traditional refereeing remain contentious issues in the sport.

1 of 2

Story summary

Keith Hackett, former Premier League referee, defended the decision not to award a penalty for Lisandro Martinez's handball during Manchester United's match against Newcastle United.
Pundit Gary Neville suggested Martinez's positioning before the incident influenced the decision.
After the match, United's coach Ruben Amorim praised Martinez's character, noting he handles pressure despite concerns about his size against taller opponents.
The incident raises questions about VAR's effectiveness in critical situations.

1 / 2