Story perspectives
Historic Totonno’s Pizzeria Set to Change Hands This Summer
12/30/2025
1 of 1
Story summary
- Antoinette Balzano, co-owner of Totonno’s, and Louise Ciminieri, co-owner and Balzano’s sister, plan to sell the business due to a lack of successors.
- Balzano says neither she nor her sister can manage the pizzeria alone, prompting the sale this summer.
- Totonno’s was established in 1924 and is among the oldest family-owned pizzerias in the U.S.
- Balzano hopes a passionate new owner who understands the legacy will take over.
