Bree Smith Files Lawsuit Against NewsChannel 5 for Alleged Sexist Abuse

Bree Smith, a former meteorologist at Tennessee's NewsChannel 5, has filed a lawsuit against her former employer and colleague Henry Rothenberg, alleging "sexist verbal abuse" and retaliation. The lawsuit, submitted on December 29, 2025, in U.S. District Court, claims that Rothenberg made derogatory comments, including telling Smith, “You only got your job because of your [breasts],” during their nine-year tenure together. Smith also alleges that Rothenberg referred to her emotional state as a result of her pregnancy, stating she was “so emotional” following the death of a close friend's child.

TV meteorologist says colleague told her she only had her job because of her breasts, lawsuit claimsThe Independent

In her lawsuit, Smith contends that Rothenberg used derogatory language towards multiple women in the workplace, both privately and in front of other industry professionals. She claims that NewsChannel 5 failed to conduct a thorough investigation into her allegations, labeling their inquiry a “sham.” Smith is seeking monetary compensation for emotional distress, humiliation, and embarrassment, as well as a fine against NewsChannel 5 to deter future misconduct.

The Independent

Smith's lawsuit also highlights her increasing workload at NewsChannel 5, which she claims escalated despite the absences of her male colleagues. She alleges that she was required to work extended hours, including a 16-hour shift when Rothenberg was absent for two days. Furthermore, Smith accuses Rothenberg of fabricating a story about his father's death, later sharing a photograph of himself with his father, who was reportedly not hospitalized.

The Independent

In response to the allegations, NewsChannel 5 has firmly rejected Smith's claims, stating that it will “aggressively” defend itself in court. The broadcaster asserts that it had negotiated to extend Smith’s contract after it expired and claims that any concerns raised by her were thoroughly investigated. NewsChannel 5 maintains that Smith's lawsuit is without merit, emphasizing that appropriate actions were taken regarding her complaints.

The Independent

Smith has expressed her distress over the impact of online harassment, particularly regarding deepfake images that have circulated using her likeness. She has publicly stated that these images weaponize her identity, leading to significant emotional turmoil. In light of her experiences, Smith has voiced support for the Tennessee “Preventing Deepfake Images Act,” which aims to address the misuse of such technology.

The Independent

While Smith's allegations detail specific instances of misconduct and retaliation, NewsChannel 5's counterclaims assert that they acted appropriately in response to her concerns. The discrepancy between Smith's account and the broadcaster's defense highlights the ongoing conflict surrounding workplace conduct and the treatment of women in the media industry.

The Independent

• “You only got your job because of your [breasts].” — Bree Smith, Former Meteorologist

The Independent

• “Any concerns brought to us by Bree were investigated thoroughly,” — NewsChannel 5 Statement

The Independent

• “I cry myself to sleep most nights, mostly because I don't want my kids to see me,” — Bree Smith, on the impact of online harassment.

The Independent