Allegations of Kickbacks in First Brands Group Bankruptcy Case

First Brands Group, an auto-parts supplier currently undergoing bankruptcy proceedings, is facing serious allegations from a group of creditors. The creditors claim that Onset Financial Inc., a major financier for the company, engaged in a kickback scheme with Edward James, the brother of First Brands' founder, Patrick James. This scheme allegedly burdened First Brands with excessive debt through predatory financing practices.

CityLab

According to the creditors' committee, Onset Financial advanced no more than $2.5 billion to First Brands but has already recouped approximately $2.9 billion. The firm is also seeking an additional $1.9 billion in claims related to the bankruptcy. The loans provided by Onset were typically short-term, maturing in less than a year, and structured with upfront payments that yielded internal rates of return exceeding 300%. The creditors allege that Edward James received hundreds of millions of dollars through fees and investment rights tied to these financing arrangements, while also suggesting that substantial funds were diverted to Patrick James personally.

CityLab

Onset Financial has dismissed the allegations as "unsupported and baseless," asserting that they are part of a "spurious scorched-earth litigation tactic." A spokesperson for Patrick James echoed this sentiment, stating that the creditor committee's claims overlook the fact that he reinvested hundreds of millions into First Brands over the years. Edward James, who resigned from First Brands on September 25, has not publicly commented on the matter.

CityLab

The creditors' committee has cited internal communications from First Brands as evidence that employees were aware of the alleged financial misconduct. They argue that Onset's actions may be a fundamental cause of the company's bankruptcy, which was filed in September 2023. The restructuring consultants now overseeing First Brands are reportedly working to unravel a series of factoring deals that involved the use of fake and inflated invoices.

CityLab

Onset Financial has characterized its dealings with First Brands as "sale-leaseback transactions" involving equipment and inventory. Following the allegations, Silver Point Capital acquired a controlling interest in the claims against First Brands and has begun to intervene in the bankruptcy case to protect Onset's interests. The creditor group is currently investigating the alleged fraud to determine if they can pursue lawsuits against executives and investors linked to First Brands' financial collapse.

CityLab

While the creditors' committee has presented a detailed account of the alleged kickback scheme, Onset Financial maintains that their transactions were legitimate. The divergence in narratives highlights the complexity of the bankruptcy case and the potential for further legal battles as investigations continue.

CityLab

• “The allegations against Onset by the First Brands Creditors’ Committee are unsupported and baseless and strategically made as part of a spurious scorched-earth litigation tactic,” — Onset Financial Representative

CityLab

• “continues to conveniently skip over the fact that hundreds of millions of dollars were reinvested into First Brands by Mr. James and related entities over the years.” — Patrick James Spokesperson

CityLab

• “appears to be a fundamental cause of these bankruptcy cases,” — First Brands Creditors’ Committee Filing

CityLab