Full Breakdown
Jessie Buckley Reflects on Her Experience in 'I'd Do Anything'
1/8/2026, 6:26:50 AM
Jessie Buckley's Experience on 'I'd Do Anything'
Jessie Buckley, the Irish actress known for her recent role in *Hamnet*, has publicly reflected on her challenging experience as a contestant on the BBC talent show *I'd Do Anything* in 2008. At just 17 years old, Buckley participated in the competition, which aimed to find an actress to play Nancy in a West End production of *Oliver!*. Ultimately, she finished as the runner-up to Jodie Prenger. In a recent interview with *Vogue*, Buckley described her time on the show as one marked by "unfair objectification" and "brutalisation."
Mental Health and Body Image Challenges
During her participation in the show, Buckley faced significant mental health struggles, admitting that she was "not fully well" and "depressed." She recounted experiences of body shaming and being subjected to what she termed "femininity school," where she was pressured to conform to certain standards of femininity. Buckley stated, "There was a lot that was really messed up," highlighting the challenges she faced while trying to navigate her identity as a young woman in the entertainment industry.
Criticism of the Show's Environment
Buckley criticized the environment of *I'd Do Anything*, recalling moments where judges and choreographers made comments about her appearance. One male choreographer reportedly urged her to adopt a more "ladylike" demeanor, while another judge's critique of her posture led to her being taught to walk in six-inch heels. Reflecting on these experiences, Buckley expressed hope that future generations of young women would not endure similar treatment, stating, "I really hope that a 15, 17, whatever-age woman never has to be brutalised quite like what happened on that show."
Official Responses and Duty of Care
In response to Buckley's comments, the BBC emphasized its commitment to the welfare of participants, noting that its policies regarding duty of care have been improved over time. The network stated that any complaints or concerns raised are treated with "the utmost care and seriousness."
Looking Back and Moving Forward
Despite the challenges she faced, Buckley acknowledged the bravery it took to participate in the show, reflecting, "I look back at it and I feel like, 'God, you're so brave.' I don’t know if I’d have that courage now." She also revealed that she declined an offer to be Prenger's understudy, stating, "I walked to his office, rang the bell and said: ‘Is Cameron Mackintosh here? Thank you, but I won’t be taking that job.’"
As Buckley continues to gain acclaim for her performances, her reflections on her early career serve as a reminder of the pressures faced by young women in the entertainment industry.
