Full Breakdown
Dog Sitter Sentenced After Assaulting Grieving Pet Owner
1/8/2026, 7:54:02 PM
Incident Overview
Owen Dempsey, a 36-year-old dog sitter from Fazakerley, Liverpool, was sentenced to 16 weeks in prison for headbutting and assaulting Martin Hulse, a grieving pet owner. The incident occurred after Hulse and his wife, Julie, returned home early from holiday to collect their deceased French bulldog, Tank, who had died while in Dempsey's care.
Background of the Case
Dempsey began dog sitting for the Hulse family in June 2024, following a positive initial experience that led them to leave five dogs, including Tank, with him for a 10-day period starting August 28. On September 8, the couple received a FaceTime call from Dempsey, informing them that Tank had died. The dog had undergone a routine operation six weeks prior but had appeared healthy before being left in Dempsey's care.
Upon returning to the UK on September 9, the Hulses found Tank's body in a plastic bag, which was reportedly not cold and had begun to emit a foul odor. Dempsey confronted Hulse, asking if he was being accused of causing the dog's death, which escalated into a physical altercation.
Assault Details
During the confrontation, Dempsey headbutted Hulse and followed up with several punches, causing Hulse to fall backward. Dempsey reportedly continued the assault until Hulse managed to push him away. After the incident, the couple contacted the police, leading to Dempsey's conviction for assault.
Legal Proceedings
Dempsey was found guilty of assault in his absence after failing to attend the trial. He also admitted to breaching a community order related to operating as an unlicensed dog boarder. A probation officer testified that Dempsey showed no remorse for his actions and had missed multiple appointments with the Probation Service.
Sentencing Remarks
District Judge Paul Healey, during sentencing, acknowledged the emotional distress experienced by the Hulse family but emphasized that Dempsey was not prosecuted for any negligence regarding Tank's death. He stated, "You assaulted Mr. Hulse. You headbutted him to the face. You punched him on a number of occasions." The judge noted Dempsey's prior convictions, including assault and affray, and his failure to comply with the terms of his community order.
Criticism & Opposition
Dempsey's defense attorney, David Kilty, argued that Dempsey had a side to the story that was not heard due to his absence at the trial. Kilty highlighted the emotional turmoil surrounding the incident, suggesting that Dempsey was under significant stress from social media accusations and targeted incidents at his home.
Conclusion
The case underscores the complexities surrounding pet care and the emotional responses that can arise from the loss of a beloved animal. Dempsey's actions and subsequent sentencing reflect the legal system's approach to addressing violence, even in emotionally charged situations.
