Story perspectives

BBC Apologizes After Controversial 'Holocaust' Comment on Celtic

1/10/2026

Summary

Given's Controversial Comment

The BBC apologized after Shay Given called Wilfried Nancy’s Celtic reign 'an absolute holocaust' on air.
Given criticized Nancy's performance after Celtic's 4-0 win over Dundee United, saying Martin O'Neill should have remained manager.
Kilmarnock, under new manager Neil McCann, drew 1-1 with Livingston, lamenting the lack of red cards for fouls.
Dundee United manager Jim Goodwin criticized VAR for not intervening on a dangerous tackle by Celtic's Julian Araujo.

Summary

Celtic's Dominant Victory

Celtic, with interim manager Martin O'Neill back in the dugout, beat Dundee United 4-0, marking a turnaround after Wilfried Nancy's brief tenure.
O'Neill shifted Celtic to a 4-3-3 formation, revitalizing the team and enabling them to dominate possession.
Hyun-Jun Yang, Arne Engels, Benjamin Nygren, and Daizen Maeda scored in the win.
Celtic aims to close the gap on league leaders Hearts, who sit three points ahead.

History

Historical Context

Martin O'Neill became Celtic's manager in June 2000, revitalizing the club after a decade of underachievement. Under his leadership, Celtic won the Scottish Premier League title in 2001, their first in ten years, and achieved a domestic treble. This historical context underscores Celtic's ongoing struggle for managerial stability and performance, particularly as they aim to reclaim dominance in Scottish football against rivals like Hearts.

1 of 3

Given's Controversial Comment

The BBC apologized after Shay Given called Wilfried Nancy’s Celtic reign 'an absolute holocaust' on air.
Given criticized Nancy's performance after Celtic's 4-0 win over Dundee United, saying Martin O'Neill should have remained manager.
Kilmarnock, under new manager Neil McCann, drew 1-1 with Livingston, lamenting the lack of red cards for fouls.
Dundee United manager Jim Goodwin criticized VAR for not intervening on a dangerous tackle by Celtic's Julian Araujo.

1 / 3