Circumcision Considered Potential Child Abuse in New CPS Guidance

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) in the UK has drafted new guidance categorizing circumcision as a potential form of child abuse. This decision arises from increasing concerns regarding the risks associated with the procedure, particularly following tragic incidents involving infants. The draft document includes circumcision alongside other harmful practices such as breast flattening and virginity testing.

The Guardian

The CPS's draft guidance comes in the wake of alarming cases, including the death of six-month-old Mohamed Abdisamad from a streptococcus infection linked to circumcision, and the death of Oliver Asante-Yeboah in 2014 due to sepsis after a circumcision performed by a rabbi. These incidents have prompted calls for stricter regulations surrounding the practice.

The Guardian

Jonathan Arkush, former president of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, criticized the CPS's characterization of circumcision as harmful, arguing that the procedure, when performed correctly, is safe and culturally significant. The Muslim Council of Britain has also expressed concern, advocating for stronger safeguards while affirming that circumcision is lawful and culturally rooted. Gordon Muir, a consultant urological surgeon, has labeled circumcision as unnecessary and potentially abusive, suggesting it should be deferred until individuals can make informed decisions.

The Guardian

Critics of the CPS guidance argue that labeling circumcision as a potential form of child abuse is misleading. Arkush stated, “To suggest that circumcision is in itself a harmful practice, is deeply pejorative and misplaced.” The Muslim Council of Britain echoed this sentiment, emphasizing that while irresponsible practices should be addressed, circumcision itself should not be characterized as abuse. Additionally, Rabbi Jonathan Romain highlighted the need for better training and regulation among practitioners to ensure safety.

The Guardian

The CPS guidance notes that while there is no specific criminal offense for male circumcision, it may be considered abusive if performed incorrectly. The document has sparked discussions among religious leaders and health professionals about the need for improved regulations and training for circumcisers. The National Secular Society welcomed the CPS guidelines but stressed the importance of preventive measures rather than relying solely on the criminal justice system.

The Guardian

• “To suggest that circumcision is in itself a harmful practice, is deeply pejorative and misplaced,” — Jonathan Arkush, Former President, Board of Deputies of British Jews

The Guardian

• “It should only be performed by doctors and, when it comes to children, only with medical necessity.” — Alejandro Sanchez, Human Rights Lead, National Secular Society

The Guardian

The CPS is expected to finalize its guidance after consultations with various stakeholders, including religious groups and health professionals. There is a growing call for a regulatory framework that ensures safe practices across all communities, with an emphasis on education and accreditation for practitioners involved in circumcision.

The Guardian