Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Rosner's Book on Jewish Identity Faces Criticism

1/12/2026

26 5

Summary

Story summary

Shmuel Rosner's 'Why Am I a Jew? A Contemporary Guide for the Perplexed' analyzes Judaism's identity and values for nonpracticing Jews, contrasting Jewish and Western values.
The work presents a range of perspectives but critics say it contains inconsistencies in its dates and source relevance.
Critics say the book lacks emotional depth and does not address the spiritual yearnings of many Jews.
The book spans 200 pages and includes endnotes.

1 of 1

Story summary

Shmuel Rosner's 'Why Am I a Jew? A Contemporary Guide for the Perplexed' analyzes Judaism's identity and values for nonpracticing Jews, contrasting Jewish and Western values.
The work presents a range of perspectives but critics say it contains inconsistencies in its dates and source relevance.
Critics say the book lacks emotional depth and does not address the spiritual yearnings of many Jews.
The book spans 200 pages and includes endnotes.