Full Breakdown
Manchester City Takes Control in Carabao Cup Semi-Final Against Newcastle
1/14/2026, 4:09:31 AM
Key Match Events
In the first leg of the Carabao Cup semi-final, Manchester City secured a 2-0 victory over Newcastle United at St. James' Park. Antoine Semenyo, who joined City from Bournemouth for £62.5 million, opened the scoring in the 53rd minute, tapping in a cross from Bernardo Silva. Semenyo later had a second goal disallowed after a lengthy VAR review, which ruled that Erling Haaland was offside and interfering with play. Rayan Cherki sealed the win with a goal in stoppage time, giving City a significant advantage heading into the second leg at the Etihad Stadium on February 4.
Controversial VAR Decision
The match was marred by controversy surrounding the disallowed goal. Semenyo's flick from a corner appeared to double City's lead, but after a six-minute VAR check, referee Chris Kavanagh ruled it out, citing Haaland's offside position as the reason for interference. This decision sparked frustration among City players and management, particularly Pep Guardiola, who expressed his discontent with the VAR process. "Four officials and VAR were not able to take the decision," Guardiola stated, emphasizing the lengthy delay and questioning the consistency of VAR interventions in previous matches.
Official Statements & Responses
Guardiola's post-match comments highlighted his frustration with VAR, referencing past incidents where he felt his team was unfairly treated. He remarked, "I would like to know why VAR in the 60th minute in the Premier League game against Newcastle... was not even considered." Semenyo also expressed disappointment, stating, "The second goal should have counted." Newcastle manager Eddie Howe acknowledged the VAR decision but noted that it was a "body blow" for his team, emphasizing the need to regroup for the second leg.
Criticism & Opposition
The VAR decision drew criticism from various quarters, including pundits and fans. Micah Richards and Jamie Redknapp voiced their concerns about the time taken for the review, with Richards stating, "VAR wasn't brought in for this reason... This was anti-goal." Chris Sutton described the decision as "incredible," questioning the rationale behind disallowing the goal. Newcastle's Dan Burn humorously remarked on the decision but ultimately recognized the complexity of the situation.
Match Analysis
Despite the disallowed goal, Manchester City demonstrated resilience and tactical prowess. The team, which has faced injury challenges, showcased depth with players like Cherki stepping up in crucial moments. Newcastle, on the other hand, struggled to convert their chances, hitting the woodwork twice and failing to capitalize on opportunities. The Magpies' inability to score left them with a daunting task for the second leg, as they seek to defend their title.
What's Next
The second leg of the semi-final will take place on February 4 at the Etihad Stadium, where Manchester City will look to maintain their advantage and secure a place in the final. Newcastle United, facing a significant challenge, will need to regroup and find a way to overcome the two-goal deficit if they hope to retain their Carabao Cup title.
