Right-Wing Media's Campaign Against Rebecca Good Following ICE Shooting

The death of Renee Good, who was shot by an ICE officer, has sparked a controversial narrative in right-wing media, focusing blame on her widow, Rebecca Good. The incident occurred when Jonathan Ross, an ICE officer, fired three bullets at Renee Good while she was driving, leading to a car crash that left Rebecca Good visibly distraught. A video capturing Rebecca Good's emotional state immediately after the shooting has been widely circulated, with right-wing commentators using it to argue for her criminal culpability.

Talking Points Memo

In the days following the incident, right-wing media outlets, including Fox News and the New York Post, amplified Rebecca Good's statement, “It’s my fault,” suggesting it could warrant a criminal investigation. Influencers like Jack Posobiec and Tim Pool have argued that Rebecca Good's presence and actions during the incident could implicate her under the felony murder rule, which holds individuals liable for deaths occurring during the commission of a crime. This narrative has gained traction, leading to calls for federal prosecutors to investigate Rebecca Good, a move that reportedly prompted the resignation of several Minnesota federal prosecutors, including Joe Thompson.

Talking Points Memo

Minnesota Governor Tim Walz expressed concern over the resignations, stating that it represents a significant loss for public safety in the state. Drew Evans, superintendent of Minnesota’s Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, noted that the departures create a vacuum of expertise that will be difficult to replace. The Trump administration's framing of the incident as a case of “domestic terrorism” has further fueled the narrative that Rebecca Good shares responsibility for her wife's death.

Talking Points Memo

Critics argue that the right-wing media's focus on blaming Rebecca Good is an attempt to divert attention from the actions of the ICE officer involved. They contend that this narrative undermines the complexities surrounding the incident and the broader implications of law enforcement practices. The push to investigate Rebecca Good has been characterized as politically motivated, aiming to shift blame away from federal law enforcement.

Talking Points Memo

While right-wing commentators assert that Rebecca Good's actions contributed to her wife's death, there is a lack of consensus on the legal implications of her statements. Some legal experts caution against interpreting her emotional remarks as admissions of guilt, emphasizing the need for a thorough investigation into the shooting itself rather than focusing on the widow's culpability.

Talking Points Memo

• “If you are in the commission of a crime, and a death occurs as a direct result of that crime, even if you didn’t commit the killing, you can become liable for it.” — Jack Posobiec, Right-Wing Activist

Talking Points Memo

• “This is a huge loss for our state.” — Tim Walz, Governor of Minnesota

Talking Points Memo

• “The BCA will continue to work on cases with the U.S. Attorney’s Office,” — Drew Evans, Superintendent of Minnesota’s Bureau of Criminal Apprehension

Talking Points Memo

The situation surrounding Renee Good's death and the subsequent media narrative highlights the contentious intersection of law enforcement, media influence, and public perception in contemporary American society.

Talking Points Memo