Story perspectives

Judge Orders Immigrant's Release; ICE Re-arrests Hours Later

1/17/2026

Center

Garrison Gibson Freed

A Minnesota judge ordered Garrison Gibson, a Liberian immigrant, released after ruling ICE entry violated his Fourth Amendment rights.
The judge ruled agents entered Gibson's home without a warrant.
Gibson was released, then re-arrested hours later at a routine check-in.
His attorney, Marc Prokosch, called the re-arrest unlawful, noting Gibson complied with supervision.
The case unfolds amid Minnesota's immigration crackdown, prompting protests after Renee Good's death by an ICE officer.

Right

Protests Erupt After Shooting

Protests intensified in Minneapolis after Renee Good was fatally shot by an agent of the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
ICE reported four arrests during protests outside the Bishop Henry Whipple Federal Building for refusing to disperse.
Authorities said 12 people were arrested for assaulting law enforcement during the unrest.
Local residents and Democrats criticized the shooting as murder, while the Trump administration defended it as justified.

History

Historical Context

The 1961 Supreme Court ruling in Mapp v. Ohio extended the exclusionary rule, which prohibits evidence obtained without a warrant under the Fourth Amendment, to state courts. This landmark decision reshaped law enforcement practices across the U.S. The recent Minnesota case involving Garrison Gibson, where a judge deemed ICE's warrantless entry unconstitutional, underscores ongoing tensions between immigration enforcement and civil rights.

1 of 3

Garrison Gibson Freed

A Minnesota judge ordered Garrison Gibson, a Liberian immigrant, released after ruling ICE entry violated his Fourth Amendment rights.
The judge ruled agents entered Gibson's home without a warrant.
Gibson was released, then re-arrested hours later at a routine check-in.
His attorney, Marc Prokosch, called the re-arrest unlawful, noting Gibson complied with supervision.
The case unfolds amid Minnesota's immigration crackdown, prompting protests after Renee Good's death by an ICE officer.

1 / 3