Renewed Calls for the Return of the Tang Honglu Well Stele from Japan to China

Chinese researchers and Japanese activists have united in a renewed effort to reclaim the Tang Honglu Well Stele, a significant relic from the Tang dynasty that was looted over 120 years ago. This initiative, spearheaded by Shanghai University’s Research Centre for Chinese Relics Overseas and various Japanese cultural groups, culminated in a joint declaration urging the Japanese government to "correct historical errors" and return the stone monument. The declaration coincided with the release of a new book titled *Compendium of Archival Documents on the Tang Honglu Well Stele*, which details the stele's historical significance and its inscriptions, which are seen as evidence of China's early sovereignty over its northeastern territories.

South China Morning PostGlobal TimesCityLabCityLabNPRIn China, Carney Just Hit ‘Code Red’ on Trade

The Tang Honglu Well Stele, weighing approximately 9.5 tons and measuring nearly 1.8 meters in height and 3 meters in width, was erected in 714 AD during the Tang dynasty, a period recognized for its cultural and artistic achievements. The stele is believed to have been taken by Japan during the Russo-Japanese War, under the pretext of being "war trophies." Historical records indicate that Japanese military officers were responsible for the systematic collection of Chinese cultural relics during this period, including the Tang Honglu Well Stele, which was later transported to Japan.

Global TimesSouth China Morning PostFinancial TimesWall Street JournalSemaforCityLab

The research center has asserted that extensive evidence supports the claim that the stele was illegally seized by Japan. They have called on the Japanese government to align with international norms regarding the return of cultural artifacts. The center emphasized the stele's importance as a symbol of China's national unity and cultural heritage, urging Japan to take "concrete actions" to rectify this historical injustice.

Global Times

While the joint declaration has garnered support from various cultural groups, there are dissenting voices in Japan. Some critics argue that the focus on historical grievances may hinder diplomatic relations between China and Japan, particularly amidst rising regional tensions. They contend that such calls for restitution could exacerbate nationalist sentiments on both sides, complicating efforts to foster cooperation.

Global Times

There is a discrepancy in the narratives surrounding the stele's history. While Chinese sources assert that the stele was taken as a war trophy, Japanese accounts may frame the acquisition differently, potentially viewing it as a legitimate collection of historical artifacts. This divergence highlights the complexities of historical interpretation and the ongoing debates over cultural heritage restitution.

Global Times

The renewed calls for the return of the Tang Honglu Well Stele are part of a broader campaign by China to reclaim cultural artifacts taken during periods of conflict. As tensions between China and Japan continue to evolve, the outcome of this cultural heritage dispute may influence diplomatic relations and public sentiment in both nations. The situation remains dynamic, with potential implications for future negotiations regarding cultural restitution and historical reconciliation.

South China Morning Post